Athletics Prospect List Sparks Debate Over Top 10 Players

A's farm system talent highlighted, but questions remain on rising star Echavarria and other nominees

Apr. 13, 2026 at 3:04am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A cubist-style painting depicting a baseball pitcher's throwing motion broken down into fragmented geometric shapes and planes in shades of green, blue, and orange.The A's farm system's wealth of pitching talent has sparked a lively debate over which young arms will make the biggest impact.Oakland Today

The Oakland A's farm system is generating excitement with a number of top prospects, including 20-year-old right-handed pitcher Steven Echavarria who recently cracked the top 10 on the Community Prospect List (CPL). However, some scouts argue Echavarria is still too raw to warrant a top 10 spot, leading to debate over his ceiling versus current growing pains. Other nominees like Mason Barnett, Tommy White, Shotaro Morii, and Cole Miller are also generating buzz as potential future contributors for the A's at the major league level.

Why it matters

The A's farm system is seen as a key part of the team's long-term rebuilding efforts, so identifying and developing top prospects is crucial. The CPL voting process engages the A's fanbase while also highlighting the differing perspectives scouts and experts have on the team's up-and-coming talent.

The details

Echavarria, a 20-year-old right-hander, has had an up-and-down second full season as a pro, but his raw talent has the A's front office excited. While he's still working on control issues, a common challenge for high school draftees, his youth and potential have him ranked 9th on the CPL. However, some scouts argue he's too raw to crack the top 10 just yet. Other nominees include Mason Barnett, a right-hander acquired in a trade who has major league experience but uneven results; Tommy White, a slugging third baseman whose bat could force his way into the lineup despite defensive limitations; Shotaro Morii, a two-way talent as both a hitter and pitcher whose ultimate role is uncertain; and Cole Miller, a 6'6" right-hander with a promising three-pitch mix who is looking to stay healthy.

  • The CPL voting process runs for 48 hours, with each vote determining the next ranked prospect.
  • Echavarria, the 9th ranked prospect, is in his second full season as a pro.

The players

Steven Echavarria

A 20-year-old right-handed pitcher in the Oakland A's farm system who has cracked the top 10 on the Community Prospect List, though some scouts argue he is still too raw to warrant that high of a ranking.

Mason Barnett

A right-handed pitcher in the A's system who was acquired in a trade, has major league experience, and possesses a four-pitch arsenal, but has had uneven results that have led to questions about whether he is a future rotation staple or just organizational depth.

Tommy White

A slugging third baseman prospect in the A's system whose bat could force his way into the lineup, though his defensive limitations may push him to first base where the A's already have a power-hitting prospect in Nick Kurtz.

Shotaro Morii

A true two-way talent in the A's system as both a hitter and pitcher, with a smooth left-handed swing and a fastball touching 95 mph, but uncertainty around whether he will ultimately focus on hitting, pitching, or try to become the next Shohei Ohtani.

Cole Miller

A 6'6" right-handed pitching prospect in the A's system with a promising three-pitch mix, who is looking to stay healthy and dominate consistently after some mechanical adjustments and an injury delay.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

The CPL voting process will continue over the next 48 hours to determine the #10 prospect on the list, with the remaining nominees moving to the next ballot alongside a new nominee. If any prospects are traded, their names will be crossed out and the list will be reshuffled, with a special vote determining the new ranking.

The takeaway

The debate over the A's top prospects highlights the differing perspectives scouts and experts have on the team's rising talent, as well as the importance of the farm system in the team's long-term rebuilding efforts. Engaging the fanbase through the CPL voting process helps generate excitement around the next wave of potential contributors to the major league club.