Stephen Colletti Doubted 'Laguna Beach' Would Succeed at First

The reality star recalls thinking MTV was 'wasting money' on casting his friend group.

Apr. 15, 2026 at 8:36pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

An abstract close-up image featuring a dramatic, high-contrast texture of glittering sequins and shattered glass, evoking the glamour and nostalgia of 2000s pop culture.The lasting legacy of 'Laguna Beach' continues to captivate audiences, even decades after the show first premiered.Laguna Beach Today

In a new podcast appearance, Stephen Colletti, a former star of the hit MTV reality series 'Laguna Beach: The Real Orange County,' revealed that he initially doubted the show would succeed. Colletti, along with his former castmate Trey Phillips, explained they were confused by the network's intense interest in documenting their high school lives, with Colletti thinking MTV was 'wasting money' on the project. However, the show went on to become a cultural phenomenon that defined mid-2000s pop culture.

Why it matters

Colletti's early skepticism about 'Laguna Beach' highlights how difficult it can be to predict the success of a new reality TV series, especially one focused on the everyday lives of a group of high school students. The show's enduring popularity and influence on the genre demonstrate the power of authentic storytelling, even when the concept may seem unconventional at first.

The details

During an appearance on the 'Teen Beat' podcast, Colletti and his former castmate Trey Phillips reflected on their initial reactions to the news that MTV wanted to document their lives in Laguna Beach, California. Colletti recalled thinking at the time that the network was essentially wasting its money by focusing on their high school experiences. Despite his early doubts, the show became a cultural phenomenon that defined mid-2000s pop culture and paved the way for modern reality storytelling.

  • The podcast episode featuring Colletti and Phillips aired on Wednesday, April 8, 2026.
  • 'Laguna Beach: The Real Orange County' first premiered on MTV in 2004.

The players

Stephen Colletti

A former star of the MTV reality series 'Laguna Beach: The Real Orange County' who initially doubted the show's potential for success.

Trey Phillips

A former castmate of Colletti's on 'Laguna Beach' who joined him on the 'Teen Beat' podcast to reflect on the show's origins.

MTV

The network that produced and aired 'Laguna Beach: The Real Orange County,' which became a cultural phenomenon despite Colletti's early skepticism.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“I was thinking, 'They're wasting their money. This is not going to work.'”

— Stephen Colletti, Former 'Laguna Beach' Star

“The transition from student to household name was a steep learning curve for the entire cast.”

— Trey Phillips, Former 'Laguna Beach' Castmate

What’s next

Fans continue to follow the lives of the 'Laguna Beach' cast, with many catching up on how the group has transitioned from high school seniors to successful adults. The cast recently reunited for 'The Reunion: Laguna Beach,' which premiered on the Roku Channel on April 10, 2026.

The takeaway

Stephen Colletti's initial doubts about 'Laguna Beach' highlight how difficult it can be to predict the success of a new reality TV concept, especially one focused on the everyday lives of high school students. The show's enduring popularity and influence on the genre demonstrate the power of authentic storytelling, even when the idea may seem unconventional at first.