Roger Ebert's Near-Perfect Review of Charlie Sheen's 1996 Sci-Fi Flop

Critic praised the intelligent storytelling and strong performances in the overlooked alien invasion thriller

Apr. 12, 2026 at 5:48am

In the summer of 1996, critics were frustrated by the perceived emptiness of big studio releases like "Twister" and "Mission: Impossible". However, Roger Ebert emerged as a staunch supporter of the intelligent and well-acted alien invasion thriller "The Arrival" starring Charlie Sheen, praising its surprising plot twists and creative visuals over the flashy action of other summer blockbusters.

Why it matters

Ebert's glowing review of "The Arrival" highlighted how the film stood out from the crowd of forgettable summer blockbusters by prioritizing coherent storytelling and character development over empty spectacle. His championing of the film helped bring attention to a thoughtful sci-fi thriller that was overlooked by many at the time.

The details

In his review, Ebert commended "The Arrival" for its surprising plot twists, strong performances, and director David Twohy's creative visuals. He was particularly fond of a major plot twist that he revealed in the review, feeling that Twohy had discovered a fresh approach to depicting an alien invasion. Ebert also noted that the film's protagonist, played by Sheen, had an enthusiasm and determination that he found endearing, even if some of the character's scientific plans were questionable.

  • The Arrival was released in the summer of 1996, at the beginning of the summer movie season.

The players

Roger Ebert

A renowned film critic who was one of the most ardent supporters of the 1996 sci-fi thriller The Arrival.

Charlie Sheen

The lead actor in The Arrival, playing a radio astronomer who believes he has intercepted an extraterrestrial signal.

David Twohy

The director of The Arrival, who Ebert praised for his creative visuals and fresh approach to depicting an alien invasion.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“The Arrival' is as clever as 'Mission: Impossible' is foolish.”

— Roger Ebert, Film Critic

“I like his attitude.”

— Roger Ebert, Film Critic

The takeaway

Ebert's enthusiastic review of The Arrival highlighted how the film stood out from the crowd of forgettable summer blockbusters by prioritizing intelligent storytelling and strong character development over empty spectacle. His championing of the film helped bring attention to a thoughtful sci-fi thriller that was overlooked by many at the time, demonstrating the power of a well-crafted review to elevate a deserving but underappreciated work.