Russell Johnson Regretted Working with Reagan on 'Law and Order'

The 'Gilligan's Island' star opened up about his political differences with the future president on the set of their 1953 Western film.

Apr. 13, 2026 at 3:03am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A minimalist, abstract composition of sharp, angular black shapes against a stark white background, conveying a sense of political tension and conflict without depicting any specific people or objects.A conceptual illustration capturing the political divide between two actors during the Red Scare in Hollywood.Tombstone Today

In his memoir, Russell Johnson, known for playing Professor Roy Hinkley on 'Gilligan's Island,' revealed his deep regret over starring alongside Ronald Reagan in the 1953 Western film 'Law and Order.' Johnson, a World War II veteran, found himself at odds with Reagan's staunchly conservative political views, which had shifted dramatically from his earlier union-supporting days. The filming took place during the height of the Red Scare in Hollywood, and Johnson's association with the allegedly communist-tied Actors Lab led to suspicions from Reagan, who saw anyone not aligned with his ultra-conservative stance as a potential communist sympathizer.

Why it matters

This story offers a unique glimpse into the complex personal and political dynamics that could play out on Hollywood sets during the turbulent McCarthy era. It highlights how differing political ideologies could create an uncomfortable working environment, even for two talented actors, and underscores the lasting impact that these divisions can have on an individual's career and personal reflections.

The details

In his book 'Here on Gilligan's Isle,' Johnson recounts his experiences on the set of 'Law and Order,' where he starred alongside Reagan as the latter's character's brother. Johnson, a decorated World War II veteran, found Reagan's political views to be 'extreme and intolerant,' particularly his testimony before the House Un-American Activities Committee, where he accused a small group within the Screen Actors Guild of communist tactics. This put Reagan at odds with the liberal Hollywood elite, including Johnson.

  • In the 1950s, the Red Scare was at its peak in Hollywood.
  • The film 'Law and Order' was produced and released in 1953.

The players

Russell Johnson

An American actor best known for his role as Professor Roy Hinkley on the sitcom 'Gilligan's Island.' He was a decorated World War II veteran and had political views that differed significantly from his co-star, Ronald Reagan.

Ronald Reagan

An American actor who would later become the 40th President of the United States. At the time of filming 'Law and Order,' he had shifted from being a union supporter to a staunch conservative, testifying before the House Un-American Activities Committee and accusing a small group within the Screen Actors Guild of communist tactics.

Nathan Juran

The director of the Western film 'Law and Order,' in which Johnson and Reagan starred.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“What I objected to was Reagan's politics. He may be a sweet man otherwise, but there were political views that we violently disagreed on.”

— Russell Johnson, Actor

The takeaway

This story highlights the lasting impact that political differences can have on personal and professional relationships, even in the glamorous world of Hollywood. It serves as a reminder that behind the scenes of iconic films and TV shows, there were often complex dynamics and ideological divides that could create an uncomfortable working environment for the actors involved.