Hawaii Lawmakers Push to Bring Prisoners Home From Arizona

HB 1769 would phase out reliance on private, out-of-state prisons, but officials warn of capacity, cost and legal risks.

Apr. 12, 2026 at 6:13pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A serene, painterly image of a lone barbed wire fence or prison guard tower set against a warm, sunlit backdrop, conveying a sense of isolation and contemplation around Hawaii's prison policies.As Hawaii weighs the human and financial costs of its reliance on out-of-state prisons, the state faces difficult decisions about how to reconnect incarcerated individuals with their families and culture.Eloy Today

Hawaii lawmakers are pushing a new proposal, HB 1769, that would force the state to start phasing out its reliance on private, out-of-state prisons and bring hundreds of incarcerated Hawaiians back home. The bill sets a 25% reduction target by July 1, 2029, with additional phased returns in subsequent years. However, state corrections officials have warned that the rapid influx of people from Arizona, without new capacity, could spark overcrowding severe enough to trigger federal intervention.

Why it matters

For decades, Hawaii has quietly shipped incarcerated individuals to the mainland, separating them from their families and cultural ties. Supporters of HB 1769 argue that returning people to the islands would reconnect them with family and culture, ultimately improving reentry outcomes, especially for Native Hawaiian men. But officials caution that the move could come with significant financial and operational challenges.

The details

HB 1769 would require the director of the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation to return committed felons who are currently housed in private, out-of-state facilities to prisons in Hawaii. The bill sets a 25% reduction target by July 1, 2029, with additional phased returns in subsequent years. Currently, about 800 Hawaii men are held at Saguaro Correctional Center in Eloy, Arizona, while the state's only medium-security men's prison, Halawa Correctional Facility, has far less available space than the number of people who would need to be returned.

  • The House approved the bill in a 50-1 vote on March 10, 2026.
  • The full Senate later advanced the bill with unanimous support.
  • The bill is now headed back to the House for more work.

The players

Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (DCR)

The state agency responsible for Hawaii's prison system, which has warned that a rapid influx of people from Arizona without new capacity could spark overcrowding severe enough to trigger federal intervention.

Halawa Correctional Facility

Hawaii's only medium-security men's prison, which has far less available space than the number of people who would need to be returned from out-of-state facilities.

Saguaro Correctional Center

A private, out-of-state prison in Eloy, Arizona where about 800 Hawaii men are currently held.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

Lawmakers now have to hammer out a final version of HB 1769 that reconciles the amended timelines with the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation's operational warnings before the bill can reach the governor's desk.

The takeaway

This debate highlights the complex tradeoffs between the human and financial costs of continuing to house Hawaii inmates out-of-state versus the capacity and budgetary challenges of bringing them back home. Ultimately, the state must balance the desire to reconnect incarcerated individuals with their families and culture against the practical realities of managing its prison system.