Trump's 'Christian Fiefdoms' Erode Democracy, Columnist Argues

The former president's preferred 'bellicose, nationalist Christianity' has alienated key voter groups, threatening brutal midterm losses for Republicans.

Apr. 17, 2026 at 4:24pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A dynamic, abstract painting featuring overlapping, geometric shapes and waves of red, white, and blue, conveying a sense of political turmoil and fragmentation.A fractured, kinetic painting captures the divisive, chaotic nature of Trump's brand of Christian nationalism and its impact on the political landscape.Casa Grande Today

A new Atlantic article examines how Donald Trump's 'erratic' and 'theologically incomprehensible' brand of Christianity, organized into various 'fiefdoms,' has subverted democracy and turned off even some of his once-loyal supporters. With the president's approval ratings plummeting and key voting blocs abandoning the GOP, the midterm elections are shaping up to be a major setback for Republicans.

Why it matters

Trump's divisive religious rhetoric and policies have fractured his coalition, jeopardizing Republican electoral prospects. The article highlights how the former president's brand of Christian nationalism has estranged independents, young voters, Latinos, and even some non-college-educated white Americans - groups crucial to his 2024 victory.

The details

The Atlantic columnists describe Trump's preferred 'bellicose, nationalist Christianity' as 'theologically incomprehensible' and organized into various 'fiefdoms.' This has alienated even some of his once-staunchest supporters, like the Arizona voter Tomas Montoya, who is now 'frustrated' and may not vote Republican in the midterms. Religious conservatives have also turned on Trump after he posted a photo of himself as Jesus and attacked the Pope. Far-right figures like pastor Joel Webbon have gone so far as to claim Trump is 'demon possessed.' The president's controversial actions, from the Epstein files to the Iran war, have further eroded his support, with some GOP operatives hoping he doesn't campaign too hard for their candidates.

  • In November 2024, Trump was re-elected as president.
  • The midterm elections are scheduled for this fall.

The players

Donald Trump

The former president whose divisive brand of Christian nationalism has fractured his political coalition.

Tomas Montoya

An Arizona voter who supported Trump in 2024 but is now 'frustrated' and may not vote Republican in the midterms.

Joel Webbon

A far-right pastor who has claimed that Trump is 'currently demon possessed.'

Riley Gaines

An anti-trans activist who wrote that 'God shall not be mocked' in response to Trump's controversial social media post.

GOP consultant

A Republican strategist who expressed concern about the potential impact of Trump's Iran war on the midterm elections.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“When Trump opens his mouth, three-quarters of what he says is stories, lies.”

— Tomas Montoya, Trump voter

“The picture [of Trump as Jesus] was 'OUTRAGEOUS blasphemy.'”

— Megan Basham, Daily Wire reporter

“God shall not be mocked.”

— Riley Gaines, Anti-trans activist

“If this is a two-week stretch, not a huge deal. If we're still bombing Iran in November? I mean ...”

— GOP consultant

What’s next

The judge in the case will decide on Tuesday whether or not to allow Walker Reed Quinn out on bail.

The takeaway

This case highlights growing concerns in the community about repeat offenders released on bail, raising questions about bail reform, public safety on SF streets, and if any special laws to govern autonomous vehicles in residential and commercial areas.