Arkansas Supreme Court Reverses Ruling in Fatal Shooting of Catholic High Student

Victim's family responds to decision, calling it a 'victory of justice'

Apr. 19, 2026 at 1:58am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

An extreme close-up photograph of a single spent shell casing on a dark surface, lit by a harsh, direct camera flash, conceptually representing the evidence and investigation of a violent crime.The Arkansas Supreme Court's decision to try the accused shooter as an adult underscores the gravity of the violent crime that took a young life.Little Rock Today

The Arkansas Supreme Court has reversed a lower court decision in a deadly shooting case from January 2025 involving the death of Catholic High School student John Allen Staats. Jeyvon Butler, who was 15 at the time, is being charged with capital murder and aggravated robbery and will now be tried as an adult.

Why it matters

This case has drawn significant attention in Arkansas, with the victim's family and state officials advocating for justice. The Supreme Court's decision to overturn the lower court's ruling and move the case to adult court is seen as an important step in holding the alleged perpetrator accountable.

The details

Testimony shows that John Staats and his twin brother went to Clement Drive to buy a gun when a person got into their car, showed two weapons, and then demanded money. A struggle followed, and John was hit in the head and shot. His brother was able to drive away to Stanton Road, where he called for help. The state's high court says the lower court incorrectly interpreted the law in moving the case to juvenile court, pointing to evidence and direct testimony from John's brother showing the crime was violent.

  • The shooting incident occurred in January 2025.
  • The Arkansas Supreme Court reversed the lower court's ruling on April 16, 2026.

The players

Jeyvon Butler

A 15-year-old charged with capital murder and aggravated robbery in the shooting death of John Allen Staats.

John Allen Staats

A Catholic High School student who was fatally shot during an alleged robbery attempt in January 2025.

Tim Griffin

The Arkansas Attorney General who filed the appeal in this case.

Will Jones

The Pulaski County Prosecutor whose office was involved in the case.

Nicholas Bronni, Cody Hiland, Barbara Webb, and Shawn Womack

The four associate justices of the Arkansas Supreme Court who ruled in favor of reversing the lower court's decision.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“April 16,2026 is a historical day. It is the victory of justice. Arkansas Supreme Court ruling brought a major step towards getting justice for our precious son John Allen Staats.”

— Shauna and Ray Staats, Parents of John Allen Staats

What’s next

The case will now return to a lower court, where Butler will be tried as an adult.

The takeaway

This case highlights the importance of the judicial system upholding justice, even in difficult cases involving minors. The Arkansas Supreme Court's decision to overturn the lower court's ruling and move the case to adult court is seen as a significant step in ensuring accountability and providing closure for the victim's family.