Sheboygan's Faye's Pizza to Expand with New Parking, Seating, and Event Space

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Faye's Pizza, a beloved Sheboygan institution that has served its signature pizza for nearly 70 years, is planning a major expansion project that will add new parking, outdoor seating, and a multi-purpose event space. The $440,000 renovation is scheduled to begin on March 9 and be completed by June 30, pending approval from the City Plan Commission.

Why it matters

As one of Sheboygan's longest-running and most iconic restaurants, Faye's Pizza expansion reflects the city's efforts to preserve its neighborhood character and support legacy businesses. The changes aim to improve customer access and experience at the popular pizza parlor.

The details

The expansion plans for Faye's Pizza include modifying vacant buildings to add more indoor space and parking, as well as creating an outdoor seating area and a new multi-purpose room that can accommodate gatherings of up to 49 people. The project will also provide direct access from an alley to the north, eliminating the need for customers to navigate Calumet Drive traffic when entering and exiting the parking lot.

• The City Plan Commission will review the project plans this afternoon.
• Construction is scheduled to begin on March 9, 2026.
• The renovations are expected to be completed by June 30, 2026.

What they’re saying

What’s next

The City Plan Commission will decide whether to approve the expansion plans for Faye's Pizza at their meeting this afternoon.