Brewers' Projected Wins: Are the Predictions Accurate?

Baseball fans in Milwaukee wonder if the Brewers can defy expectations again in 2026.

Apr. 11, 2026 at 1:43pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A cubist, geometric painting depicting a baseball game in motion, with overlapping planes of navy blue, gold, and forest green representing the dynamic action on the field.The Brewers' ability to defy expectations has become a captivating narrative, leaving analysts and fans alike eager to see if the team can once again exceed preseason projections.Today in Milwaukee

The Milwaukee Brewers have consistently outperformed preseason projections over the past two seasons, leaving fans and analysts puzzled. While advanced metrics like PECOTA suggest the team may regress in 2026, the Brewers have proven they can exceed expectations. This article explores the debate around the Brewers' future performance and whether the projection systems are accurately capturing their potential.

Why it matters

The Brewers' ability to outperform projections has been a source of fascination in the baseball world. If they can do it again, it could challenge the limitations of predictive models and force a re-evaluation of how we analyze team performance. The outcome also has major implications for the Brewers' fanbase and their hopes for a successful 2026 season.

The details

The PECOTA projection system has consistently ranked the Brewers lower than their on-field results suggest. Baseball Prospectus' Jonathan Judge points to the team's high error rate in 2025 as a potential indicator of luck rather than sustainable skill. However, the Brewers' strong offense, which finished third in the league in runs scored, raises questions about the validity of these projections. Additionally, the breakout performances of young players like Turang and Priester have the projection models skeptical of their ability to replicate that success, despite the players' upward trajectory.

  • The Brewers outperformed expectations in the 2025 season.
  • The 2026 MLB season is approaching.

The players

Jonathan Judge

An analyst at Baseball Prospectus who has discussed the Brewers' 2025 season and the team's projected performance.

Turang

A Brewers player who had a breakout season in 2025 after initial struggles, raising questions about the projection models' ability to accurately forecast his future performance.

Priester

Another Brewers player who had a breakout season in 2025 after initial struggles, leading to skepticism from projection models about his ability to sustain that success.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“The Brewers led the league in errors committed against them. This could indicate a stroke of good luck rather than a sustainable skill.”

— Jonathan Judge, Analyst, Baseball Prospectus

“The Brewers' slugging percentage was average at best, and their isolated power ranked 25th in the league. However, the team's ability to score runs was evident, finishing third in baseball with 806 runs in 2025.”

— Jonathan Judge, Analyst, Baseball Prospectus

What’s next

The Brewers' performance in the 2026 season will be closely watched to see if they can once again defy the projections and exceed expectations.

The takeaway

The Brewers' ability to outperform preseason projections has become a fascinating storyline in baseball. If they can do it again in 2026, it could challenge the limitations of predictive models and force a re-evaluation of how we analyze team performance. The outcome will have major implications for the Brewers' fanbase and their hopes for a successful season.