Former Healthcare Leaders Criticize Wenatchee Cancer Clinic Plans

Concerns raised over lack of physician input and strained relationship between Confluence Health and local doctors

Published on Feb. 24, 2026

Two former healthcare executives, Dr. Peter Rutherford and Jack Evans, have spoken out against the proposed $60 million cancer care clinic in Wenatchee, Washington, citing a lack of strategic input and collaboration with the local Wenatchee Valley Medical Group (WVMG). They warn that the fractured relationship between Confluence Health and the physicians group could have serious consequences for the region's healthcare system.

Why it matters

The dispute over the cancer clinic highlights ongoing tensions between the leadership of Confluence Health, the largest healthcare provider in North Central Washington, and the independent physicians group that makes up the majority of the region's doctors. Resolving these issues is crucial for maintaining a cohesive and high-quality regional healthcare system.

The details

According to the former CEOs, the overwhelming majority of WVMG physicians have expressed a lack of confidence in Confluence Health CEO Andrew Jones. Rutherford and Evans, who were involved in the original affiliation between Central Washington Hospital and Wenatchee Valley Medical Center that formed Confluence Health in 2012, say the unified response from WVMG is rare and signals deep organizational problems. They warn that without restoring alignment between physicians and system leadership, the consequences could include difficulty recruiting and retaining doctors, declining morale, and reduced access to specialized services.

  • The Confluence Health and Wenatchee Valley Medical Center affiliation was formed in 2012 and is set to expire in 2027, unless renewed.
  • The $60 million Cancer Center project was recently approved by the Confluence Health Board.

The players

Dr. Peter Rutherford

Former CEO of Confluence Health.

Jack Evans

Former CEO of Central Washington Hospital at the time Confluence Health was formed.

Andrew Jones

Current CEO of Confluence Health.

Wenatchee Valley Medical Group (WVMG)

The largest affiliated physicians group in the region.

Confluence Health

The largest healthcare provider in North Central Washington, formed through the affiliation of Central Washington Hospital and Wenatchee Valley Medical Center.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“if alignment between physicians and system leadership is not restored, the consequences could include difficulty recruiting and retaining physicians, declining morale, and reduced access to specialized services.”

— Dr. Peter Rutherford and Jack Evans, Former healthcare leaders (kissin977.com)

“the unified response by WVMG is rare and signals deep organizational problems exist between CH and local doctors.”

— Dr. Peter Rutherford and Jack Evans, Former healthcare leaders (kissin977.com)

What’s next

The Confluence Health Board is being urged to renew the vetting process for the $60 million Cancer Center project to ensure better collaboration and transparency with the local physician group.

The takeaway

This dispute highlights the importance of maintaining strong relationships and alignment between healthcare system leadership and the physicians who provide care in the community. Resolving these issues will be crucial for ensuring the future of high-quality, accessible healthcare in the Wenatchee region.