Honey Lemon Cheesecake Recipe Celebrates 50 Years of The Antique Sandwich Co.

This creamy, honey-sweetened cheesecake is an elegant make-ahead dessert from the iconic Tacoma, WA eatery.

Mar. 15, 2026 at 7:00pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The Antique Sandwich Co. in Tacoma, Washington is celebrating over 50 years in business, having started as an antiques shop with a sandwich counter in the back in 1973. The shop's signature honey lemon cheesecake recipe, which has been a beloved menu item for decades, is now being shared with the public.

Why it matters

The Antique Sandwich Co. is a beloved community institution that has weathered changing times in Tacoma, maintaining its commitment to nostalgic, homemade fare. This recipe showcases the shop's enduring appeal and the sweet treats that have kept customers coming back for over half a century.

The details

The honey-sweetened cheesecake features a graham cracker crust, a creamy filling made with cream cheese, honey, eggs, powdered milk, lemon juice and vanilla, and a topping of sour cream, lemon juice and honey. The cheesecake is baked until the center is firm, then cooled and chilled before being drizzled with more honey.

  • The Antique Sandwich Co. opened in Tacoma, Washington in 1973.

The players

The Antique Sandwich Co.

A nostalgic eatery in Tacoma, Washington that started as an antiques shop with a sandwich counter in the back in 1973 and is now better known for its homemade fare, including a signature honey lemon cheesecake.

Arlene Herridge

The founder who opened the original antiques shop in 1973.

Tamie

Arlene's daughter, who started selling sandwiches in the back of the shop.

Shirley

Tamie's daughter-in-law, who also helped with the sandwich business.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Fifty years is such an accomplishment in Tacoma, especially with the way the city has changed over the years.”

— Gordon Edgar, Grocery employee

What’s next

The Antique Sandwich Co. is hosting a 50th anniversary celebration this weekend with special menu items, live music, and more.

The takeaway

The Antique Sandwich Co.'s enduring success and beloved honey lemon cheesecake recipe is a testament to the power of community-driven, mission-based businesses that can withstand the test of time.