NFL Faces Risks in Replacement Ref Plan

League's push for more training and accountability for officials could backfire if negotiations with referees' union fail.

Mar. 27, 2026 at 10:03am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The NFL is considering using replacement referees if it cannot reach a new labor agreement with the NFL Referees Association (NFLRA) before the current pact expires on May 31. However, this strategy carries significant risks, as the league learned in 2012 when replacement officials led to controversial calls and damaged the integrity of the game. The NFL is emphasizing the need for improved training, development and accountability for officials, but the referees' union has leverage and is resisting the league's demands.

Why it matters

The integrity of the game is at stake if the NFL is forced to use replacement officials who lack the experience and expertise of the regular crews. This could lead to high-profile mistakes and controversies that undermine fan confidence in the sport, as happened in 2012. The referees also play a key role in enforcing player safety rules, so their absence could raise concerns from the players' union.

The details

The NFL and NFLRA have been engaged in tough labor negotiations for nearly two years, with the union accusing the league of sending an "empty suit" to recent talks and the league saying the union has refused to engage meaningfully. The NFL is preparing to use officials from the college ranks as replacements, and is also considering a rule change to allow expanded use of instant replay to correct "clear and obvious" mistakes by the replacement crews.

  • The current labor agreement between the NFL and NFLRA expires on May 31, 2026.
  • In 2012, the NFL used replacement officials for the first month of the season before reaching a new deal with the regular crews.

The players

Scott Green

Head of the NFL Referees Association, the union representing the league's officials.

Roger Goodell

Commissioner of the National Football League.

Jeff Miller

Executive Vice President of the National Football League.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Instead of wasting their money on something that has failed before, we should be at the negotiating table settling our differences.”

— Scott Green, Head of the NFL Referees Association

“We continue to focus on investing in accountability and performance in our officiating department. Scott and his team haven't changed their approach in almost two years, continuing to demand raises at almost double the rates of the increases realized by the players over the course of this CBA and, in addition, millions of dollars in marketing fees that rank-and-file union members never see.”

— Jeff Miller, Executive Vice President, National Football League

What’s next

Next week, NFL owners will consider a proposal to allow expanded use of instant replay to correct "clear and obvious" mistakes by replacement officials.

The takeaway

The NFL's plan to use replacement referees if negotiations with the officials' union fail carries significant risks to the integrity of the game, as the league learned in 2012. The referees have leverage due to their importance in enforcing player safety rules and maintaining credibility, which the league must weigh against its desire for more training and accountability.