Longtime Mattituck Resident Shirley S. Anderson Dies at 95

Anderson was a force of nature and second mother to many in the community.

Apr. 2, 2026 at 10:55pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

An abstracted, out-of-focus photograph in soft, warm tones depicting a serene coastal scene with sailboats and cottages, conveying the peaceful lifestyle that Shirley S. Anderson enjoyed for decades.The tranquil waterfront setting that Shirley S. Anderson called home for nearly a century reflects the quiet dignity and community spirit that defined her life.Richmond Today

Shirley S. Anderson, a longtime resident of Mattituck, New York, passed away on March 14, 2026, at the age of 95. Anderson was known as a 'force of nature' and a second mother to many in the community, having been involved with the Presbyterian Church, local clubs, and frequently hosting gatherings at her home overlooking the Great Peconic Bay.

Why it matters

Shirley S. Anderson's passing marks the end of an era for the tight-knit Mattituck community, where she had lived since 1932 and was a beloved figure known for her generosity, community involvement, and love of the outdoors. Her life story reflects the changing tides of Long Island's North Fork region over the past century.

The details

Born in 1930 in Mineola, Anderson attended Syracuse University and spent her younger years raising five children. She was an educator with the Orton Society, now known as the International Dyslexia Association, for over 60 years. Anderson lived in the same Mattituck home since 1932, which became her permanent year-round residence in 1989. She was involved with the local Presbyterian church, frequently hosted dinner parties and gatherings, and remained active in clubs like the Lionesses. Anderson loved sailing, boating, and walking in the water in front of her home, which many in the community referred to as 'Camp Mineola'.

  • Shirley S. Anderson was born on June 30, 1930.
  • Anderson passed away on March 14, 2026, at the age of 95.
  • A celebration of life will be held on Saturday, June 27, 2026.

The players

Shirley S. Anderson

A longtime resident of Mattituck, New York, who passed away at the age of 95. Anderson was known as a 'force of nature' and a second mother to many in the community, having been involved with the local Presbyterian church, clubs, and frequently hosting gatherings at her home overlooking the Great Peconic Bay.

Robert Anderson

Shirley S. Anderson's late husband.

Wayne Anderson

Shirley S. Anderson's late son.

Brian Anderson

One of Shirley S. Anderson's surviving children, living in Mattituck.

Glenn Anderson

One of Shirley S. Anderson's surviving children, living in Mattituck.

Dean Anderson

One of Shirley S. Anderson's surviving children, living in Huntington.

Alene Harrington

One of Shirley S. Anderson's surviving children, living in Richmond, Virginia.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

A celebration of life for Shirley S. Anderson will be held on Saturday, June 27, 2026, at the family's home in Mattituck, officiated by the Rev. Dr. Peter J. Kelley.

The takeaway

Shirley S. Anderson's passing marks the end of an era for the tight-knit Mattituck community, where she had been a beloved and active figure for nearly a century. Her life story reflects the changing tides of Long Island's North Fork region and the enduring power of community, family, and a deep connection to the natural environment.