Utah Student Journalism Bill Stalls Over Free Speech Concerns

Lawmakers raise issues with balancing student rights and school oversight.

Jan. 28, 2026 at 6:39pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A proposal to expand the rights of student journalists in Utah while protecting their advisers from liability failed to move forward this week. The bill, HB227, would have given student journalists the right to exercise freedom of speech and press in school-sponsored media, but lawmakers on the House Education Committee expressed concerns about the measure, citing a Supreme Court decision that found schools can regulate student speech to some degree.

Why it matters

The debate over the student journalism bill highlights the ongoing tension between protecting student free speech rights and allowing schools to maintain control over the educational environment. Supporters argue the bill would empower student voices, while opponents worry it could undermine a school's ability to fulfill its educational mission.

The details

The bill, sponsored by Rep. Carol Spackman Moss, D-Holladay, would have allowed schools to block the publication of student journalism only if it is obscene, libelous, violates the law or school policy, or creates a needless invasion of privacy. It also would have protected student media advisers from discipline for protecting students' work. However, multiple Utah lawmakers expressed concerns about the proposal, citing a 1988 Supreme Court decision that found schools can regulate student speech in school-sponsored activities as long as their actions are 'reasonably related to legitimate pedagogical concerns.'

  • The House Education Committee voted 9-3 to table HB227 on January 28, 2026, effectively halting its progress for the remainder of the legislative session.

The players

Rep. Carol Spackman Moss

The Democratic representative from Holladay who sponsored the student journalism bill, HB227.

Milan Venegas

A high school graduate from Utah County who shared an example of an article he wrote as a student journalist that was critical of his school administration.

Rep. Karen Peterson

The Republican representative from Clinton who noted the U.S. Supreme Court has outlined a difference between student and professional journalists.

Rep. Karianne Lisonbee

The Republican representative from Syracuse who cited the Supreme Court case as a reason she had 'serious concerns' about HB227.

Maryann Christensen

The executive director of Utah Legislative Watch who opposed the bill, arguing that students 'just need guidance while they're in school.'

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“This seems probably out of balance.”

— Rep. Karianne Lisonbee (ksltv.com)

“There is power in what the students can say. They just need guidance while they're in school.”

— Maryann Christensen, executive director of Utah Legislative Watch (ksltv.com)

What’s next

The student journalism bill will not move forward during the current legislative session, but its supporters may seek to revise and reintroduce it in the future.

The takeaway

The debate over the student journalism bill in Utah highlights the ongoing challenge of balancing student free speech rights with a school's need to maintain control over the educational environment. While supporters argue the bill would empower student voices, opponents are concerned it could undermine a school's ability to fulfill its educational mission.