Judge Allows Cameras at Next Hearing for Accused Killer of Conservative Leader

Tyler James Robinson's lawyers argued against cameras and public access to documents, but the judge ruled the public's right to an open proceeding outweighs the defense's concerns.

Mar. 14, 2026 at 9:18pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A Utah County judge ruled that cameras and media access will be allowed at the April 17 hearing for Tyler James Robinson, the 22-year-old man accused of killing conservative leader and Arizona resident Charlie Kirk. Robinson's lawyers had argued against cameras and limiting public access to certain documents, citing concerns about prejudicial pretrial publicity, but the judge rejected those motions, saying the public's interest in an open proceeding outweighs the defense's concerns.

Why it matters

This case has garnered significant media attention given the high-profile nature of the victim, conservative leader Charlie Kirk, and the potential for the death penalty if Robinson is convicted. The judge's ruling on cameras and public access reflects the importance of transparency in high-profile criminal proceedings, even as the defense seeks to limit what information is made public.

The details

During a pretrial hearing, Fourth Judicial District Court Judge Tony Graf Jr. ruled against Robinson's lawyers' motions to exclude cameras during the April 17 hearing and limit public access to certain documents in the case. The ruling means video and still cameras and microphones will be allowed at the hearing. Robinson's lawyers argued there was a great deal of prejudicial and inaccurate pretrial publicity that would hurt Robinson's chances to get an impartial jury, but the judge said the defendant has not provided a sufficient basis to limit public access and the presumptive right to an open proceeding.

  • The April 17 hearing will allow cameras and media access.
  • Defense lawyers have until March 30 to file a motion requesting which segments of the April 17 hearing would be closed.

The players

Tyler James Robinson

A 22-year-old man accused of killing conservative leader and Arizona resident Charlie Kirk.

Judge Tony Graf Jr.

The Fourth Judicial District Court judge who ruled against the defense's motions to exclude cameras and limit public access to documents in the case.

Charlie Kirk

The conservative leader and co-founder of Turning Point USA who was killed during a rally in Utah.

Jeff Gray

The Utah County Attorney who has said he will seek the death penalty if Robinson is convicted of murder.

Michael Burt

One of Robinson's defense attorneys who argued against cameras and limiting public access to documents.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“In balance, the defendant has not provided a sufficient basis for the court to find that the interests favoring closure outweigh the interest favoring an open proceeding and the presumptive right to access.”

— Judge Tony Graf Jr. (dailyfly.com)

“To say this is a content tornado, with a barrage of media coverage, doesn't necessarily mean there's going to be prejudice against the defendant.”

— Christopher Ballard, Prosecutor (dailyfly.com)

What’s next

The judge said defense lawyers had until March 30 to file a motion requesting which segments of the April 17 hearing would be closed.

The takeaway

This case highlights the ongoing tension between a defendant's right to a fair trial and the public's interest in transparency, especially in high-profile criminal proceedings. The judge's ruling reflects the presumption that court proceedings should be open to the public unless the defense can demonstrate a clear and specific threat to the fairness of the trial.