The 'Party Switch' Between Republicans And Democrats Is A Myth, Says Author

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

In a new book, author Claston Bernard challenges the common narrative of a 'party switch' between Republicans and Democrats, arguing that Black political support had already begun shifting toward the Democratic Party long before the Civil Rights era. Bernard contends that under Democratic presidents like Woodrow Wilson and Franklin D. Roosevelt, policies and postures often excluded or disempowered Black Americans, despite the party's later embrace. The author says the idea that Democrats suddenly became champions of Black Americans while Republicans became villains is 'propaganda' and the truth is more complex.

Why it matters

This perspective provides an alternative historical analysis of the evolution of the Democratic and Republican parties' relationships with the Black electorate, challenging a widely accepted narrative. It raises questions about the motivations and trade-offs involved in the gradual political realignment of Black voters over the 20th century.

The details

According to Bernard, even before the Civil Rights era, Black political support had already begun shifting toward the Democratic Party. Under Woodrow Wilson's presidency in the early 1900s, the Democratic administration segregated the federal government and empowered the Ku Klux Klan, despite praise from figures like W.E.B. Du Bois. By the 1930s, roughly 35% of Black voters were supporting Democrats, dismantling the claim that the shift happened due to a sudden 'party switch.' Bernard argues that Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal policies, while sold as economic relief, often excluded or disempowered Black Americans through discriminatory implementation. By the time Lyndon B. Johnson expanded the welfare state in the 1960s, over 60% of Black voters were already aligned with the Democratic Party. The author contends this was not due to a moral transformation, but a strategic shift where 'promises of government support replaced the earlier Republican emphasis on self-determination, property ownership, and enterprise.'

• In the early 1900s, under Woodrow Wilson's presidency, the Democratic administration segregated the federal government and empowered the Ku Klux Klan.
• By the 1930s, roughly 35% of Black voters were already supporting the Democratic Party.
• By the time Lyndon B. Johnson expanded the welfare state through the Great Society in the 1960s, over 60% of Black voters were firmly aligned with the Democratic Party.

What they’re saying