Dallas Sports Rivals Face Off in High-Stakes Legal Battle

Stars' bankruptcy case dismissal sets stage for Texas court showdown with Mavericks over franchise agreements and relocations

Apr. 11, 2026 at 12:38pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A cubist, geometric painting depicting the abstracted shapes of a basketball court and ice hockey rink, with intersecting planes of deep blue, green, and red colors representing the legal conflict between the Dallas Mavericks and Dallas Stars.The legal battle between Dallas' rival sports franchises is a complex tangle of franchise agreements, relocation disputes, and high-stakes courtroom drama.Dallas Today

The Dallas Stars' attempt to reopen a 15-year-old bankruptcy case has been shut down by a Delaware judge, marking an early defeat in the NHL team's high-stakes legal battle against the Dallas Mavericks. The two franchises are suing each other over alleged breaches of their franchise agreements with the City of Dallas, with the Stars claiming the Mavericks violated their deal by shifting operations to Las Vegas in 2024, while the Mavericks argue the Stars breached their agreement by moving their headquarters to Frisco in 2003.

Why it matters

This ruling raises questions about the precedent it could set for how sports teams handle disputes over franchise agreements and relocation, as both the Stars and Mavericks accuse each other of violating their respective deals with the city. The case highlights the complex power dynamics between professional sports franchises, local governments, and the courts.

The details

In the Delaware bankruptcy court hearing, Stars CEO Jim Lites testified that Mavericks executives were aware of the Stars' Frisco headquarters move as early as the 2000s. The Stars argued their 2011 bankruptcy confirmation order should shield them from future objections, but the Mavericks countered that the current parties were not part of the original case. Judge Owens sided with the Mavericks, stating the Texas Business Court should determine the issues. Now the case heads to Texas, with a virtual hearing set for January 22 and a potential jury trial in May.

  • The Stars' bankruptcy case dismissal occurred on Monday, April 11, 2026.
  • A virtual hearing in the Texas Business Court is scheduled for January 22, 2026.
  • A potential jury trial in the Texas case is set for May 2026.

The players

Dallas Stars

A National Hockey League (NHL) team based in Dallas, Texas.

Dallas Mavericks

A National Basketball Association (NBA) team based in Dallas, Texas.

Judge Karen B. Owens

The U.S. Bankruptcy Court judge who denied the Stars' motion to reopen their 15-year-old bankruptcy case.

Jim Lites

The CEO of the Dallas Stars.

Charles 'Chip' Babcock

The lead attorney representing the Dallas Mavericks in the legal battle.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Texas Business Court can determine these issues in the ordinary course of business … I think you're best to focus your attention in Texas.”

— Judge Karen B. Owens, U.S. Bankruptcy Court Judge

What’s next

The case will now proceed in the Texas Business Court, with a virtual hearing scheduled for January 22, 2026, followed by a potential jury trial in May 2026. Four critical hearings, including a motion for summary judgment on January 26, could potentially resolve the case before it reaches a jury.

The takeaway

This legal battle between the Dallas Stars and Dallas Mavericks highlights the complex power dynamics between professional sports franchises, local governments, and the courts. The outcome could set a precedent for how teams handle disputes over franchise agreements and relocation, with both sides accusing the other of violating their respective deals with the city.