Manziel Confident 2012 Aggies Would Stomp 2025 Vanderbilt

Former Heisman winner believes his historic Texas A&M squad would dominate modern-day Commodores

Jan. 30, 2026 at 6:23pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

In a hypothetical matchup between two of college football's most dynamic quarterbacks from different eras, former Texas A&M star Johnny Manziel has boldly claimed that his 2012 Aggies squad would easily defeat the 2025 Vanderbilt team led by Heisman finalist Diego Pavia. Manziel, the first freshman to win the Heisman Trophy, believes his high-powered offense and supporting cast would overwhelm the modern-day Commodores.

Why it matters

This debate pits two of the most exciting college football players of their respective generations against each other, sparking discussions about how the game has evolved and which era would come out on top. It also highlights the enduring legacy of Manziel's historic 2012 season at Texas A&M, which helped elevate the program to new heights.

The details

On the Glory Daze Podcast, Pavia joined the discussion and Manziel boldly claimed that the 2012 Aggies would "stomp" Pavia's 2025 Vanderbilt squad. Manziel had over 700 more yards of total offense and 8 more touchdowns than Pavia's Heisman finalist campaign. The 2012 Aggies also featured star wide receiver Mike Evans, who went on to an illustrious NFL career, and tight end Malcome Kennedy, who was second on the team in receiving that season.

  • Manziel's historic 2012 season at Texas A&M
  • Pavia's Heisman finalist campaign with Vanderbilt in 2025

The players

Johnny Manziel

Former Texas A&M quarterback who won the Heisman Trophy in 2012, becoming the first freshman to do so.

Diego Pavia

Vanderbilt quarterback who was a Heisman finalist in 2025.

Mike Evans

Star wide receiver for Texas A&M in 2012 who went on to a successful NFL career.

Malcome Kennedy

Tight end for Texas A&M in 2012 who was second on the team in receiving that season.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“We'd beat you guys by 25”

— Johnny Manziel

The takeaway

This hypothetical matchup between two of college football's most electrifying quarterbacks from different eras highlights the enduring legacy of Manziel's historic 2012 season at Texas A&M and the program's rise to prominence in the modern game. While the outcome can never be known, the debate sparks discussions about the evolution of the sport and which era would come out on top.