Casey's Breakfast Pizza Earns Rave Reviews in Amarillo

Convenience store chain's new location in Amarillo draws crowds for its highly anticipated breakfast pizza offering.

Mar. 10, 2026 at 1:03pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

After much anticipation, the new Casey's General Store in Amarillo, Texas has opened and is drawing crowds for its breakfast pizza. A local reviewer tried the build-your-own breakfast pizza and was impressed by the delicious crust, cheese sauce, eggs, and meat toppings, declaring it 'a piece of heaven.' The large 12-slice pizza is priced at $17.99 and the reviewer says it was worth every penny, providing enough for leftovers on Sunday as well.

Why it matters

Casey's entry into the Amarillo market is significant, as the convenience store chain is known for its high-quality food offerings that have built a loyal customer base across the Midwest. The popularity of the breakfast pizza highlights how Casey's is differentiating itself from competitors and attracting new customers in the Texas Panhandle region.

The details

The reviewer ordered a half-and-half breakfast pizza, with one side featuring bacon and the other sausage. She praised the perfectly seasoned sausage, salty bacon, and delicious cheese sauce as the standout components that made the pizza so enjoyable. Customers can also customize the pizza with other meat and veggie toppings like chorizo or swap the cheese sauce for sausage gravy.

  • Casey's General Store officially opened in Amarillo on February 20, 2026.
  • The reviewer tried the breakfast pizza on a weekend shortly after the store opened.

The players

Casey's General Store

A convenience store chain known for its high-quality food offerings, including the popular breakfast pizza that has drawn crowds to its new Amarillo location.

Lori Crofford

A local reviewer who tried the Casey's breakfast pizza in Amarillo and shared her honest, positive assessment of the product.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“OH MY GOSH, the hype was true. This breakfast pizza was a piece of heaven.”

— Lori Crofford, Reviewer

What’s next

Casey's plans to open additional locations in the Amarillo area, including in the nearby town of Claude and at the intersection of Bell Street and Loop 335.

The takeaway

Casey's breakfast pizza has quickly become a hit with Amarillo residents, demonstrating the convenience store chain's ability to differentiate itself through high-quality, craveable food offerings that can draw loyal customers even in new markets.