Republicans Oppose Immigrant Detention Centers in Their Own Backyards

GOP lawmakers push back against DHS plans to convert warehouses into large-scale detention facilities in rural communities

Apr. 4, 2026 at 3:07pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Republican lawmakers and local officials are opposing the Department of Homeland Security's plans to rapidly expand immigrant detention by converting warehouses into large-scale detention centers in rural communities across the country. Despite previously supporting the Trump administration's deportation agenda, GOP leaders are now voicing concerns about the strain these facilities would place on local infrastructure and resources.

Why it matters

The Republican pushback highlights the growing tensions over the federal government's aggressive efforts to scale up immigrant detention, even in conservative-leaning areas that have historically supported tough immigration enforcement. Experts warn the warehouse detention model could lead to further dehumanization and deaths of detainees, while also straining small communities that lack the resources to support such large detention facilities.

The details

DHS plans to use $39 billion to overhaul its detention model, including building eight mega-sites that could each hold up to 10,000 immigrants. This would create detention facilities larger than the largest federal prison in the U.S. However, Republican governors, senators, and local officials have joined Democrats in opposing these plans, citing concerns about the impact on their communities' infrastructure and resources. In states like New Hampshire, Mississippi, Tennessee, Georgia, and Pennsylvania, GOP leaders have successfully lobbied to halt or delay DHS's warehouse acquisition plans.

  • In 2025, there were 31 known detainee deaths in immigrant detention, the highest in 20 years.
  • So far in 2026, more than a dozen immigrants have already died in detention.

The players

Kelly Ayotte

The Republican governor of New Hampshire who released documents about DHS's plans to convert a warehouse in Merrimack into an immigrant detention center.

Marsha Blackburn

A Republican U.S. Senator from Tennessee who petitioned DHS to halt plans for a mega-detention center in Lebanon that could hold up to 16,000 immigrants.

Roger Wicker

A Republican U.S. Senator from Mississippi who wrote a letter to DHS asking the agency to look elsewhere for a proposed 8,500-bed detention center in the rural town of Byhalia.

Eric Taylor

The city manager for Social Circle, Georgia, who placed a lock on a water meter to prevent access to a warehouse purchased by ICE for a large-scale detention facility.

Josh Shapiro

The Democratic governor of Pennsylvania who said he will use his legal and regulatory power to prevent the siting of immigrant detention centers in the state.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“I'm all for helping DHS, and I'm behind that to make sure we get rid of these illegal criminals that have been throughout our country, but I also understand Social Circle's concerns, from not just the infrastructure but the resources that may be needed.”

— Mike Collins, U.S. Representative

“Existing medical and human services infrastructure in Byhalia is insufficient to support such a large detainee population. Establishing a detention center at this site would place significant strain on local resources.”

— Roger Wicker, U.S. Senator

What’s next

The newly confirmed Homeland Security Secretary, Markwayne Mullin, has pledged to work with local communities concerned about the large detention centers. However, DHS officials have stressed that the pause on purchasing more warehouses may only be temporary.

The takeaway

The Republican pushback against DHS's plans to rapidly expand immigrant detention in rural communities highlights the growing tensions over the federal government's aggressive deportation agenda. Even in conservative areas that have historically supported tough immigration enforcement, local leaders are voicing concerns about the strain these large-scale detention facilities would place on their communities' resources and infrastructure.