Small Town's Identity Battle Over Christian Nationalism

Residents of Gainesboro, Tennessee fight against influence of conservative Christian development

Apr. 11, 2026 at 11:08am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A warm, nostalgic painting depicting the steeple of an old church in a small town, with the building bathed in soft, golden light and surrounded by deep shadows, conveying a sense of quiet contemplation and the struggle to preserve a community's traditional identity.The serene town of Gainesboro faces a battle over its identity as conservative Christian influences seek to reshape its community values.Gainesboro Today

The quiet town of Gainesboro, Tennessee has found itself at the center of a heated debate over Christian nationalism. The controversy began when a prominent conservative figure, Josh Abbotoy, developed a community called Ridgerunner that attracted two self-proclaimed Christian nationalists with extreme views. This has sparked concerns among local residents who fear the influence of these individuals and their potential impact on the town's values. The situation has escalated as the two men, Andrew Isker and C Jay Engel, have encouraged their followers to move into small communities and exert local influence.

Why it matters

This story reflects a broader political struggle in rural America, where Republicans have made significant gains and the Democratic Party is now focusing its efforts. The debate in Gainesboro highlights the tension between those who want to preserve the town's traditional values and those who seek to impose a Christian nationalist agenda, raising questions about the role of religion in politics and the preservation of community identity.

The details

Abbotoy's development, Ridgerunner, initially attracted little attention, but a local TV news report in late 2024 brought it to the forefront of public discourse. The report highlighted controversial statements from Isker and Engel, who have expressed views questioning the value of female suffrage, advocating for mass deportations of legal immigrants, and even suggesting the repeal of the 20th Century. This has caused alarm among some local residents, who fear the influence of these individuals. Abbotoy, however, dismisses these concerns, emphasizing his focus on creating a peaceful and community-oriented environment. In response, a group of locals, led by Diana Mandli, a prominent businesswoman, organized an informal resistance, displaying messages opposing the new development and engaging in direct confrontations with Isker and Engel.

  • In late 2024, a local TV news report brought Ridgerunner and the views of Isker and Engel to the forefront of public discourse.
  • The situation has escalated as Isker and Engel, through their podcast Contra Mundum, have encouraged their followers to move into small communities and exert local influence.

The players

Josh Abbotoy

A prominent figure in US conservative circles who developed the Ridgerunner community in Gainesboro, Tennessee.

Andrew Isker

A self-proclaimed Christian nationalist with extreme views, including questioning the value of female suffrage and advocating for mass deportations of legal immigrants.

C Jay Engel

A self-proclaimed Christian nationalist with extreme views, including suggesting the repeal of the 20th Century.

Diana Mandli

A prominent businesswoman in Gainesboro who led a group of locals in organizing an informal resistance against the influence of Isker and Engel.

Nan Coons

A resident of Gainesboro with deep roots in the area, determined to protect the town's values and prevent the influence of extreme views.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“We must not let individuals continue to damage the values and identity of our community.”

— Diana Mandli, Businesswoman

“Our focus is on creating a peaceful and community-oriented environment, not on political agendas.”

— Josh Abbotoy, Developer

What’s next

The town's residents are determined to continue their resistance against what they perceive as a threat to their community, even as Abbotoy's development continues to attract attention and controversy.

The takeaway

This story highlights the ongoing struggle in rural America between those who seek to preserve traditional community values and those who promote a Christian nationalist agenda. The debate in Gainesboro reflects the broader political and cultural tensions that are shaping the country's future.