Identities Revealed in Mysterious 1976 South Carolina Homicide

Victims Pamela Mae Buckley and James Paul Freund had no known connection, leaving investigators puzzled

Published on Feb. 25, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The bodies of a young man and woman were discovered alongside a rural South Carolina road in 1976, but their identities remained unknown for decades. Forensic genealogy has now revealed the victims as Pamela Mae Buckley, a 25-year-old musician from Minnesota, and James Paul Freund, a 30-year-old from Pennsylvania. Authorities are still trying to determine why the two were together and who killed them.

Why it matters

This cold case has baffled investigators for over 45 years. The revelation of the victims' identities provides new leads, but also raises more questions about their connection and the circumstances surrounding their deaths. Solving this mysterious double homicide could bring closure to the victims' families and communities.

The details

Buckley and Freund's bodies were found facedown and shot in the back of the head on August 9, 1976 near Lynchburg, South Carolina. Buckley was a 25-year-old musician from Minnesota who had been reported missing 8 months earlier, while Freund was a 30-year-old from Pennsylvania who had never been officially declared missing. Investigators are still trying to determine why the two were together so far from their homes and who killed them.

  • Buckley's body was discovered on August 9, 1976 alongside Old St. John Church Road in Lynchburg, South Carolina.
  • Buckley had been reported missing 8 months prior in Colorado.
  • Freund had no known missing persons report filed, despite his body being found alongside Buckley's.

The players

Pamela Mae Buckley

A 25-year-old musician from Redwood Falls, Minnesota who was a member of the folk trio Sunlending. She had been reported missing 8 months prior to her body's discovery in South Carolina.

James Paul Freund

A 30-year-old man from Lancaster, Pennsylvania whose body was found alongside Buckley's. He had never been officially reported as missing.

Ira Parnell

The Sumter County Sheriff at the time who arranged for the unidentified victims' burials at Bethel United Methodist Church.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“After failed attempts to identify the two young victims, the Sumter County Sheriff at the time, Ira Parnell, arranged for their burials at Bethel United Methodist Church.”

— Ira Parnell, Sumter County Sheriff (postbulletin.com)

What’s next

At a 2021 press conference, authorities with the Sumter County Sheriff's Office said there was at least one person of interest they planned to pursue. The Sheriff's Office has not responded to recent interview requests about any updates in the case.

The takeaway

This tragic cold case has haunted the Sumter County community for over four decades. The identification of the victims provides some answers, but also raises new questions about their connection and the circumstances surrounding their mysterious deaths. Solving this case could bring long-awaited closure to the victims' families and communities.