New COLAtoday Readers Share Their Favorite Columbia Restaurants

From longtime local staples to newer spots, these 10 eateries were mentioned most by new subscribers.

Published on Mar. 5, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

When new readers subscribe to COLAtoday, the local news site asks them to share their favorite restaurant in the Columbia, South Carolina area. After sorting through recent responses, a few clear favorites rose to the top, including longtime local staples and newer spots across the Midlands.

Why it matters

This list provides valuable insight into the dining preferences of COLAtoday's growing readership, highlighting the diverse and vibrant restaurant scene in the Columbia metropolitan area.

The details

The top 10 favorite restaurants mentioned by new COLAtoday subscribers include a mix of Italian, Mexican, Southern, and French-inspired eateries located throughout the city's neighborhoods, from Devine Street to the Vista to Five Points and West Columbia. These establishments serve house-made pastas, wood-fired pizzas, elevated Mexican dishes, fresh coastal classics, and more, showcasing the culinary creativity and variety found in the Columbia food scene.

  • COLAtoday asked new subscribers about their favorite restaurants in recent welcome emails.

The players

Il Giorgione

A local Devine Street favorite serving house-made pastas, wood-fired pizzas, and classic Italian dishes.

COA Agaveria y Cocina

The lively Vista restaurant serving elevated Mexican dishes like tacos de pibil, aguachile verde, and carne brava, plus an extensive tequila and mezcal selection.

Motor Supply Company Bistro

A longtime Vista staple with a daily-changing seasonal menu and a recent Michelin Guide recommendation.

Lula Drake Wine Parlour

The award-winning intimate wine bar on Main Street featuring an extensive wine list and thoughtful small plates.

Blue Marlin

The Southern seafood institution in the Vista known for shrimp and grits and fresh coastal classics.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

The takeaway

This list of favorite Columbia restaurants highlights the diverse and vibrant dining scene in the city, with a mix of longtime local staples and newer standouts serving a range of cuisines. It showcases the culinary creativity and community-driven values that make Columbia's food culture so appealing to residents and visitors alike.