Anderson County Murder Trial Continues, Closing Arguments Expected Friday

Jurors hear testimony from jailhouse informant and forensic pathologist as defense rests case

Published on Feb. 27, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The trial continues for a woman accused of killing four family members in 2015 in Anderson County, South Carolina. On the fourth day of trial, jurors heard from a jailhouse informant who claimed the defendant discussed the murders, as well as testimony from a forensic pathologist who detailed the victims' injuries. The defense rested its case on Thursday, and closing arguments are expected on Friday morning.

Why it matters

This high-profile murder trial has drawn significant attention in the local community, with many residents following the case closely. The outcome could have major implications for the defendant and her family, as well as broader discussions around criminal justice and forensic evidence.

The details

Jurors heard testimony from Jackie Phillips, who said she shared a jail cell with the defendant, Amy Valardi, for over a week in 2024. Phillips claimed Valardi discussed 'corralling' the victims into the living room before 'he did the deed.' However, the defense argued Phillips provided this information to investigators in an attempt to secure a deal, and pointed out inconsistencies between her account and the victims' causes of death, which were primarily knife wounds. The jury also heard from forensic pathologist Dr. Kyle Shaw, who detailed the victims' injuries, including gunshot and stab wounds. Shaw said he could not determine if one or more people caused the injuries. The defense rested its case on Thursday without calling additional witnesses.

  • The trial began in February 2026.
  • Closing arguments are expected on Friday, February 27, 2026 at 9 a.m.

The players

Amy Valardi

The woman accused of killing four family members in 2015 in Anderson County, South Carolina.

Jackie Phillips

A woman who testified that she shared a jail cell with the defendant, Amy Valardi, for over a week in 2024 and claimed Valardi discussed the murders.

Heather Weiss

The state prosecutor in the case.

Lori Murray

One of the defense attorneys for the defendant, Amy Valardi.

Dr. Kyle Shaw

The Anderson County forensic pathologist who testified about the victims' injuries.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“And how many people are in that particular pod”

— Heather Weiss, State Prosecutor (wspa.com)

“There's two people to a cell.”

— Jackie Phillips (wspa.com)

“I was really kind of struck by her comment when she said they had corralled them into the living room and he did the deed. And I was like 'so you shot them', and she went like that.”

— Jackie Phillips (wspa.com)

“The victims died of knife wounds. And then they were shot post-mortem. It doesn't really make any sense to say that she corralled them and he shot them. Does it?”

— Lori Murray, Defense Attorney (wspa.com)

“The left of her neck, below the left side of her jaw, is a stab wound.”

— Dr. Kyle Shaw, Forensic Pathologist (wspa.com)

What’s next

The judge will provide final instructions to the jury on Friday morning, and the jury will then begin deliberations to determine a verdict.

The takeaway

This high-profile murder trial has highlighted the complex and often conflicting nature of forensic evidence and witness testimony, raising questions about the reliability of jailhouse informants and the challenges of establishing a clear timeline and sequence of events in a brutal crime. The outcome will be closely watched by the local community as they seek justice and closure.