SB Nation Reacts: Where should Oneil Cruz play for Pirates?

Fans weigh in on the best position for the young slugger.

Apr. 11, 2026 at 4:11pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A fragmented, geometric painting in bold colors depicting a baseball player in motion, with the figure broken down into sharp, overlapping planes to conceptually represent the complex positional decision facing the Pirates.A cubist interpretation of the debate over where to play young Pirates star Oneil Cruz, balancing his offensive potential and defensive struggles.Today in Pittsburgh

According to the latest SB Nation Reacts survey, a plurality of Pirates fans believe Oneil Cruz should be the team's designated hitter rather than playing in the field, where he has struggled defensively. The 23-year-old has shown promise at the plate but has made multiple errors in center field, leading to calls for the team to find a more suitable position for the young slugger.

Why it matters

Determining the best position for Oneil Cruz is a critical decision for the Pirates as they look to maximize the potential of their young star. His offensive production has been a bright spot, but his defensive struggles in center field have been a concern. Finding the right balance between his bat and glove will be key to his long-term development and the team's success.

The details

In the latest SB Nation Reacts survey, 42% of Pirates fans said they believe Cruz should be the team's designated hitter, rather than playing in the field. The 23-year-old has hit .292 with 4 home runs and 12 RBIs so far this season, but has also made multiple errors in center field, leading to calls for a position change.

  • Oneil Cruz has played 25 games for the Pirates so far this season.

The players

Oneil Cruz

A 23-year-old outfielder for the Pittsburgh Pirates who has shown promise at the plate but struggled defensively in center field.

Marcell Ozuna

The Pirates' current designated hitter, whose role could be impacted if the team decides to move Oneil Cruz to that position.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Cruz continues top show that he is a liability at center field and a change might need to happen sooner rather than later.”

— Ethan-Coulehan, Author

What’s next

The Pirates will need to evaluate Oneil Cruz's long-term position as they look to maximize his offensive potential while addressing his defensive shortcomings.

The takeaway

The debate over Oneil Cruz's best position highlights the challenges the Pirates face in balancing his offensive strengths and defensive weaknesses. Finding the right fit for the young slugger will be crucial for the team's success.