Ex-Player Calls Out Pirates for Not Signing Andrew McCutchen

Argues McCutchen could have mentored top prospect Konnor Griffin

Published on Mar. 5, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A former MLB player criticized the Pittsburgh Pirates for not re-signing veteran outfielder Andrew McCutchen this offseason, arguing that McCutchen's presence could have been invaluable in mentoring top prospect Konnor Griffin and helping develop the young player.

Why it matters

The Pirates are in a rebuilding phase and have a strong crop of young talent, including Griffin, who is competing for a roster spot this spring. Bringing back McCutchen, even in a reduced role, could have provided veteran leadership and guidance to help accelerate the development of the team's top prospects.

The details

During an appearance on the 'Foul Territory' podcast, former All-Star catcher AJ Pierzynski criticized the Pirates' decision not to re-sign McCutchen, arguing that the 18-year MLB veteran could have greatly benefited the team's young players, especially Griffin, by providing advice and mentorship on how to be a successful big leaguer.

  • The Pirates decided not to bring back Andrew McCutchen for the 2026 season.
  • McCutchen signed a minor league deal with the Texas Rangers this offseason.
  • Konnor Griffin is competing for a spot on the Pirates' Opening Day roster in 2026 spring training.

The players

Andrew McCutchen

A former NL MVP and five-time All-Star outfielder who spent the majority of his career with the Pittsburgh Pirates.

Konnor Griffin

A top prospect in the Pirates' organization who is competing for a roster spot in 2026 spring training.

AJ Pierzynski

A former two-time MLB All-Star catcher who is now a commentator on the 'Foul Territory' podcast.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“[McCutchen] gives you professional at-bats all the time. Think about how good Konnor Griffin could be if he could watch Andrew McCutchen's at-bats. And you can have Andrew McCutchen in the dugout talking to him about pitchers, talking to him about situations, talking to him about how to be a big leaguer. That's invaluable.”

— AJ Pierzynski, Former MLB Player (Foul Territory)

What’s next

The Pirates will have to decide whether Konnor Griffin makes the Opening Day roster after his strong spring training performance.

The takeaway

This situation highlights the value veteran players can provide to young, rebuilding teams, even if their on-field production has declined. The Pirates may have missed an opportunity to accelerate the development of one of their top prospects by not bringing back Andrew McCutchen.