South Philly Residents Fight FDR Park Renovations

Judge rules lawsuit against $250 million overhaul can proceed despite city's objections

Published on Feb. 7, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A group of South Philadelphia residents have filed a lawsuit to stop the $250 million renovation of FDR Park, arguing the plans will "radically change and undermine the purpose of FDR Park" by replacing natural vegetation with artificial turf fields and requiring paid permits to use the new facilities. A judge has ruled that the residents' lawsuit can move forward, rejecting the city's claim that the residents waited too long to file the suit.

Why it matters

The renovation of FDR Park is a major project that will significantly alter one of Philadelphia's most popular public green spaces. The residents argue the changes, including the addition of artificial turf fields and removal of trees, will negatively impact the character and accessibility of the park. The outcome of this lawsuit could determine the future of the park's development.

The details

The $250 million renovation plan led by the Fairmount Park Conservancy includes the addition of a dozen new artificial turf athletic fields, six new baseball fields, tennis and basketball courts, a new welcome center, and new nature trails and wetlands. Construction is already underway on some of the new facilities. The residents argue the turf fields will be toxic and the removal of trees will undermine the park's purpose. The city counters that the park will remain public with the same mix of active and passive recreation as before, just with updated facilities.

  • In 2022, the Philadelphia International Airport cut down roughly 58 acres of trees and vegetation in the Southwest corner of the park.
  • In 2024, the Conservancy cut down 48 large 'heritage' trees in a former golf course area on the park's west side.

The players

Rich Garella

A South Philadelphia resident who is the lead petitioner in the lawsuit against the FDR Park renovations.

Fairmount Park Conservancy

The nonprofit leading the $250 million renovation of FDR Park.

Philadelphia Department of Parks & Recreation

The city agency overseeing the FDR Park renovation project.

Judge Sheila Woods-Skipper

The Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas judge who ruled that the residents' lawsuit against the FDR Park renovations can move forward.

Sam Stretton

The lawyer representing the South Philadelphia residents in the lawsuit against the FDR Park renovations.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

The judge will next consider the residents' request for an order to halt the renovation work at FDR Park as the first basketball courts and artificial turf athletic field get under construction.

The takeaway

This lawsuit highlights the tension between preserving the character and accessibility of a beloved public green space and the desire to modernize and upgrade its facilities. The outcome could set an important precedent for how major park renovations are evaluated and approved in Philadelphia.