Judge Orders Trump Admin to Mitigate Damage to Slavery Exhibit Panels

Philadelphia fights removal of memorial honoring enslaved individuals at President's House site

Feb. 3, 2026 at 7:15pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

U.S. District Judge Cynthia Rufe has ordered the Trump administration to securely store and mitigate any further deterioration or damage to the 34 panels of a slavery exhibit that were removed from the President's House site in Philadelphia. The panels tell the stories of the nine enslaved Africans who were held by President George Washington at the site. The city of Philadelphia is suing the Trump administration over the removal of the exhibit.

Why it matters

The President's House site and memorial are an important historical and cultural landmark that honors the lives of enslaved individuals who lived there during the nation's founding. The removal of the exhibit panels by the National Park Service has sparked outrage and a legal battle over preserving this significant piece of history.

The details

Judge Rufe inspected the condition of the panels, which are currently stored at the National Constitution Center, and found some exhibited damage. She ordered the federal government to mitigate any further deterioration or damage to the panels as the lawsuit over their removal moves forward. The city of Philadelphia and the Avenging the Ancestors Coalition advocacy group have argued the removal and storage of the panels has been disrespectful and amounts to 'desecration' of the historical site.

  • On January 22, the National Park Service removed the 34 panels from the President's House site.
  • On February 3, Judge Rufe filed an inspection report and issued an order barring any further removal or destruction of the site.

The players

Judge Cynthia Rufe

The U.S. District Judge overseeing Philadelphia's federal lawsuit against the Trump administration over the removal of the slavery exhibit.

City of Philadelphia

The plaintiff in the federal lawsuit seeking to block the Trump administration from making further changes to the President's House site.

Avenging the Ancestors Coalition

An advocacy group that launched the campaign in 2002 to include a slavery memorial at the President's House site and has filed a motion to support the city's lawsuit.

Michael Coard

The attorney and founder of the Avenging the Ancestors Coalition who participated in the inspection of the stored exhibit panels.

National Park Service

The federal agency that removed the 34 panels from the President's House site on January 22.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“There were scratches and marks on several of the 34 items we saw, there was no cushioning. They were up against the wall. They were on the cement floor. Had they slipped, the glass items would have fallen to the ground.”

— Michael Coard, Attorney and founder, Avenging the Ancestors Coalition (ktlo.com)

“I can't say, being quite candid, that there was any damage, there was no damage, but there was desecration, and for me, it's the same thing.”

— Michael Coard, Attorney and founder, Avenging the Ancestors Coalition (ktlo.com)

What’s next

Judge Rufe will continue to consider the city of Philadelphia's motion for a preliminary injunction to block the Trump administration from making any further changes to the President's House site as the lawsuit moves forward.

The takeaway

The removal and storage of the slavery exhibit panels at the President's House site has sparked outrage and a legal battle over preserving this important historical and cultural landmark that honors the lives of enslaved individuals who lived there during the nation's founding.