Exploring the Controversial Legacy of President James Buchanan at Wheatland

Pennsylvania's only president left a divisive mark on history, as preserved in his Lancaster County home

Published on Feb. 18, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Wheatland, the historic Lancaster County home of President James Buchanan, stands as a testament to preservation, but Buchanan's legacy as one of America's most controversial presidents has been far less kind. As the nation pauses to honor its leaders this Presidents' Day, the story of Buchanan offers a cautionary tale about the consequences of indecision and political detachment during a time of deep division.

Why it matters

Buchanan's presidency is often ranked among the nation's least effective, as his southern sympathies and failure to address the growing tensions over slavery laid the groundwork for the Civil War. Exploring Buchanan's legacy at Wheatland provides important lessons about the lasting impact of political leadership, or lack thereof, during pivotal moments in history.

The details

Wheatland, Buchanan's preserved home, contains roughly half of the original objects owned by the 15th president. While the house stands as a testament to preservation, Buchanan's legacy has been heavily criticized. As a career politician who was largely removed from the contentious debates over slavery, Buchanan entered office hoping to calm sectional tensions, but his actions instead deepened the divisions that led to the Civil War.

  • Buchanan served as president from 1857 to 1861.
  • Wheatland, Buchanan's historic Lancaster County home, is now a museum managed by a historian.

The players

James Buchanan

The 15th president of the United States, who is often ranked among the nation's least effective presidents due to his failure to address the growing tensions over slavery during his time in office.

Stephanie Celiberti

The manager and historian of Wheatland, Buchanan's preserved historic home in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“We make no bones about it. He is one of our worst presidents in our nation's history.”

— Stephanie Celiberti, Manager and historian of Wheatland

“If we don't learn about the failures and mistakes that he made as a president, we're not going to be able to move forward as a nation.”

— Stephanie Celiberti, Manager and historian of Wheatland

What’s next

As the nation reflects on the legacy of its presidents this Presidents' Day, the story of James Buchanan and Wheatland serves as a reminder of the importance of political leadership and the lasting consequences of indecision during times of crisis.

The takeaway

Buchanan's presidency, preserved in the historic Wheatland home, offers a cautionary tale about the dangers of political detachment and the need to confront difficult issues head-on, even at the risk of deepening divisions. By learning from Buchanan's failures, the nation can better navigate the challenges of the present and future.