Judge Dismisses Lawsuit in Death of Blair Co. Corrections Officer

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit related to the 2021 death of Blair County corrections officer Rhonda Russell, who was killed by a police sergeant during a hostage situation at a courthouse. The judge ruled that the actions taken by Altoona Police Sergeant George Bistline, who fired the fatal shot, met constitutional standards of 'reasonableness'.

Why it matters

This case highlights the difficult decisions law enforcement officers must make in high-stress, life-threatening situations, and the legal standards that govern the use of lethal force. The dismissal of the lawsuit suggests the court found Bistline's actions justified, despite the tragic outcome of an officer-involved shooting.

The details

Rhonda Russell, a Blair County corrections officer, was taken hostage by inmate Christopher Aikens while the two were alone in a holding cell area at Blair Central Court in Altoona. Aikens used Russell as a human shield, took her gun, and pointed it at Sergeant Bistline when he arrived to help. Bistline retreated, pulled his own gun, and shot and killed Russell instead of Aikens.

• The incident occurred in 2021.
• The federal judge dismissed the lawsuit on February 25, 2026.

What’s next

The judge's dismissal of the lawsuit with prejudice means the case cannot be refiled, except for any civil charges against Bistline's estate and the city of Altoona.