Second Stillwater Teen Faces Rape Charges Amid Unequal Treatment Claims

Payne County pursues case against another teenager accused of similar but lesser crimes.

Published on Feb. 10, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A Stillwater high school student convicted of sexual assault, who last year became the focus of national attention for what critics called a lenient sentence, is again under scrutiny as Payne County pursues a case against another teenager accused of similar but lesser crimes.

Why it matters

The case has raised questions about potential unequal treatment and sentencing disparities in the criminal justice system, particularly when it comes to sexual assault charges involving teenage defendants.

The details

The new case involves a Stillwater high school student who is facing rape charges, while the previous case last year involved a different Stillwater teen who received a more lenient sentence for a sexual assault conviction.

  • The previous case involving a Stillwater teen and a sexual assault conviction occurred last year.
  • The new case against another Stillwater teen on rape charges is currently being pursued by Payne County.

The players

Jesse

A Stillwater high school student who is facing the new rape charges.

Payne County

The county pursuing the case against the Stillwater teen accused of rape.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

The judge in the new case will determine whether the Stillwater teen accused of rape will be tried as an adult or a juvenile.

The takeaway

This case has reignited concerns about potential disparities in how the criminal justice system handles sexual assault cases, particularly when the defendants are teenagers, and highlights the need for more consistent and equitable treatment.