Coney Island: Still Holding Down Lunch Like It's 1924

Oklahoma City's original Coney Island has been serving up affordable, hearty lunches for over a century.

Feb. 5, 2026 at 11:15am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Since 1924, Oklahoma City's original Coney Island restaurant, located in the Capitol Hill neighborhood, has been serving up affordable and filling lunches to the local community. The restaurant has maintained its classic diner-style menu and atmosphere for over a century, providing a taste of nostalgia and tradition in the ever-changing city.

Why it matters

Coney Island's longevity in a city that has seen significant development and change over the past century is a testament to the restaurant's ability to cater to the needs of its local community. As many small, independent restaurants struggle to stay afloat, Coney Island's continued success highlights the value that classic, affordable eateries can provide to neighborhoods.

The details

Coney Island first opened its doors in 1924 and has remained a fixture in Oklahoma City's Capitol Hill neighborhood ever since. The restaurant is known for its classic diner-style menu, featuring items like hot dogs, burgers, and milkshakes at affordable prices. Despite the changing landscape of the city, Coney Island has maintained its nostalgic atmosphere and loyal customer base, continuing to serve as a gathering place for the local community.

  • Coney Island first opened in 1924.

The players

Coney Island

An iconic diner-style restaurant that has been serving affordable, hearty lunches in Oklahoma City's Capitol Hill neighborhood since 1924.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

The takeaway

Coney Island's enduring presence in Oklahoma City's Capitol Hill neighborhood is a testament to the value that classic, community-oriented restaurants can provide. In an era of rapid development and changing tastes, Coney Island has managed to maintain its traditional diner-style menu and atmosphere, continuing to serve as a gathering place for locals who appreciate its affordable, nostalgic offerings.