Dayton Bookstore Ordered to Vacate Indefinitely After Nuisance Notice

Rabbit Hole Books faces closure as city cites building violations, leaving owners scrambling to reopen before key sales seasons.

Apr. 7, 2026 at 2:22am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A high-end, photorealistic studio still-life photograph featuring a stack of well-worn, vintage hardcover books in muted earth tones, resting on a clean, monochromatic seamless background. The lighting is sharp and dramatic, with deep shadows to conceptually represent the fragility of independent businesses facing bureaucratic obstacles.A stack of beloved books sits idle, symbolizing the struggle of an independent bookstore to overcome bureaucratic hurdles and reopen its doors to the community.Today in Dayton

Rabbit Hole Books, an independent bookstore in Dayton, Ohio, has been ordered to vacate its premises indefinitely after the city's Public Nuisance Board cited numerous building code violations, including exposed electrical wiring, facade damage, and lack of a fire alarm system. The store's executive director says the city failed to properly notify the building's attorney about the hearing, preventing them from attending and contesting the decision. With permits still pending and the store filled with inventory, the owners are now racing against the clock to complete repairs and reopen before missing out on crucial sales periods like Valentine's Day and St. Patrick's Day.

Why it matters

Rabbit Hole Books is a beloved community institution in Dayton, serving as a 'shining star' for local readers and writers. Its potential closure would be a major loss for the city's cultural landscape, especially as small, independent bookstores continue to face challenges from online retailers and the pandemic's impact on in-person shopping. The dispute also highlights tensions between small businesses and municipal authorities over building code enforcement and the impact it can have on neighborhood vitality.

The details

After a fire in an adjacent parking garage in February, a city inspection of Rabbit Hole Books uncovered numerous building code violations, including exposed electrical wiring, damage to the facade, lack of a fire alarm system, and extensive damage to the building's concrete. This led the city to issue a public nuisance notice, forcing the closure of the sidewalk in front of the store. The store's executive director, Larkin Vonalt, says the city has made the process of addressing the violations and reopening 'more laborious' at every step, with permits still pending a week after being submitted. When Vonalt drove by the store over the weekend, she found a notice taped to the door ordering the space to be vacated indefinitely following a hearing by the city's Public Nuisance Board, which the building's attorney was not notified about and therefore did not attend.

  • In February, a fire in an adjacent parking garage led to a city inspection of Rabbit Hole Books.
  • Over a week ago, the store's owners submitted permit requests to begin repairs, but they have not yet been processed.
  • This past weekend, Vonalt discovered a notice on the door ordering the store to vacate indefinitely after a Public Nuisance Board hearing.

The players

Rabbit Hole Books

An independent bookstore in Dayton, Ohio that serves as a beloved community institution and 'shining star' for local readers and writers.

Larkin Vonalt

The executive director of the Dayton Book Fair and spokesperson for Rabbit Hole Books, who has been navigating the store's struggle to reopen after being ordered to vacate.

City of Dayton

The municipal authority that cited Rabbit Hole Books for numerous building code violations and ordered the store to vacate its premises indefinitely after a Public Nuisance Board hearing.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Every step is made more laborious. Our engineer has made a game plan. The building owner has filed a permit request, and although we were assured that that would be processed quickly, it's been a week tomorrow without it.”

— Larkin Vonalt, Executive Director, Dayton Book Fair

“We really want the city to help us. We're not the enemy. We want the city to get the paperwork approved so that we can get the mason who's on standby to come and do the work.”

— Larkin Vonalt, Executive Director, Dayton Book Fair

“I worry that people will think erroneously that the store isn't safe. I mean, the city has made such a big deal about the building being unsafe when the building isn't unsafe. I'm concerned that, you know, people won't come down because they're worried that, you know, they could be injured here.”

— Larkin Vonalt, Executive Director, Dayton Book Fair

What’s next

Rabbit Hole Books' owners are awaiting the processing of their permit requests so they can begin the necessary repairs to address the city's code violations and reopen the store. They have scheduled a grand reopening event for April 23, which is William Shakespeare's birthday, but it remains uncertain whether they will be able to meet that target date.

The takeaway

This dispute between Rabbit Hole Books and the City of Dayton highlights the challenges small, independent businesses can face when navigating municipal building code enforcement, especially when communication and cooperation between the two sides breaks down. The potential closure of this beloved community institution underscores the fragility of local cultural hubs in the face of bureaucratic obstacles.