SMU Coach Defends NCAA Tournament Bid Amid Injured Star's Absence

Andy Enfield says SMU deserved a spot in the Big Dance despite losing BJ Edwards to injury before the First Four game.

Mar. 19, 2026 at 2:20pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

In the final First Four game of the 2026 NCAA Tournament, No. 11 Miami (OH) defeated No. 11 SMU 89-79. SMU was without senior guard BJ Edwards, who was injured on Feb. 25 and had not played since. Prior to the Selection Show, SMU had claimed Edwards would be ready for Tournament play, which was a factor in the team receiving the final at-large bid. However, Edwards was ultimately ruled out just before the First Four game. SMU head coach Andy Enfield defended the team's NCAA Tournament selection, saying their body of work and metrics deserved a spot regardless of Edwards' status.

Why it matters

The controversy around BJ Edwards' injury status and SMU's inclusion in the NCAA Tournament raises questions about how much weight the selection committee places on a team's full-strength roster versus their overall performance and metrics throughout the season.

The details

SMU lost four of its last five games heading into the Tournament after Edwards was injured on Feb. 25. Despite this late-season slide, the selection committee cited SMU's NET ranking of 37 and quality of wins as reasons for including them in the field, banking on Edwards' return. However, Edwards was ultimately ruled out just before the First Four game, dealing a big blow to SMU's chances.

  • On Feb. 25, BJ Edwards was injured in SMU's 73-69 loss to Cal.
  • Prior to the Selection Show, SMU released a statement claiming Edwards would be ready for Tournament play.
  • On March 19, Edwards was ruled out just two hours before SMU's First Four game against Miami (OH).

The players

Andy Enfield

The head coach of the SMU Mustangs basketball team.

BJ Edwards

A senior guard for the SMU Mustangs who was injured on Feb. 25 and missed the team's First Four game.

Keith Gill

The chairperson of the NCAA Tournament Selection Committee.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“If you look at our whole body of work, we deserved to be in the NCAA Tournament. Our NET was 37, with the quality of wins we had. BJ is important, but it's a team sport. A lot of other teams have injuries. We deserved to be in the NCAA Tournament if you looked at all of our metrics and our wins.”

— Andy Enfield, Head Coach, SMU Mustangs

“Six games ago, they lost one of their important players (Edwards). They've lost five of six of those games. He's coming back. He's the third-leading scorer and is a defensive player. Their quality of wins, along with them getting back to full strength, gave them that last spot.”

— Keith Gill, NCAA Tournament Selection Committee Chairperson

What’s next

The NCAA Tournament Selection Committee will likely face scrutiny over how they evaluate teams with key injuries in the future.

The takeaway

This case highlights the difficult balance the NCAA Tournament selection committee must strike between rewarding teams' overall body of work versus projecting how they will perform at full strength. It also raises questions about transparency and accountability around injury status claims made by teams.