Ohio State Fans Debate National Titles vs. Rivalry Wins

Buckeyes fans prioritize national championships over beating Michigan, but the rivalry remains a key barometer for the program.

Apr. 8, 2026 at 7:35pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A fragmented, cubist-style painting depicting the action and energy of a college football rivalry game, with sharp geometric shapes and planes in the team colors of Ohio State and Michigan.The intense rivalry between Ohio State and Michigan is a microcosm of the emotional pull of college football, where institutional pride and local loyalties can sometimes overshadow the pursuit of national glory.Columbus Today

The debate over whether college football provides a more compelling experience than the NFL often centers on the emotional intensity and tribal loyalty inherent in the collegiate game. For Ohio State fans, this tension is exemplified by the conflict between achieving the ultimate goal of a national championship and the traditional necessity of defeating their primary rival, the University of Michigan.

Why it matters

Ohio State's recent national championship victory coincided with a period of struggle in their rivalry with Michigan, raising questions about how the program balances these competing priorities. The fan base's perspective on this issue provides insight into the unique culture and expectations surrounding major college football programs.

The details

Ohio State recently secured national championship redemption, though the victory coincided with a four-game losing streak against Michigan. In a 2025 survey, 89.3% of Buckeye fans agreed that winning a national title is more important than beating the Wolverines. However, the fan base remains heavily influenced by the outcome of the annual Michigan game, with expectations for head coach Ryan Day increasing after the championship run.

  • On November 30, 2024, Michigan defeated Ohio State 13-10 in Columbus.
  • In May 2025, a survey of over 1,000 Ohio State fans was conducted.

The players

Ryan Day

The head coach of the Ohio State Buckeyes, who currently stands as one of only three active coaches with a national championship.

Jack Sawyer

An Ohio State player who asserted that winning a national championship is more important than winning the game against Michigan.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Winning a national championship is more important than winning the game against Michigan.”

— Jack Sawyer, Ohio State player

“Another pucker in The Game would cause the fan base to grab their pitchforks and five back into 'Fire John Cooper 2.0' mode.”

— Reader

“No NFL game could top the intensity of a matchup between Ohio State and Michigan or UCLA and USC.”

— Ria Naraian, Website editor

What’s next

As the program moves forward, the expanded College Football Playoff has raised questions about whether the importance of traditional rivalries will diminish. While the ultimate goal remains the national championship, the emotional weight of the rivalry with Michigan continues to serve as a primary barometer for the program's health and the stability of the coaching staff.

The takeaway

The debate over college football's superiority to the NFL often centers on the unique atmosphere and motivation found in the collegiate ranks, with fans placing a high value on the pride and nationalist sentiment they feel toward their connected institutions. However, Ohio State's recent experience highlights the tension between achieving national titles and maintaining dominance in traditional rivalries, an issue that will continue to shape the program's future.