Whitehall Council Meeting Ends Abruptly After Member Addresses Sex Crime Charges

Council member refuses to stop commentary about another member accused of sex crimes involving minors

Feb. 3, 2026 at 10:07pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A Whitehall City Council meeting ended abruptly after a council member, Devin Brown, refused to stop speaking about sex crime charges against fellow council member Gerald Dixon that were later dropped. Council President Thomas Potter repeatedly tried to stop Brown's speech and threatened to adjourn the meeting early if he didn't, but Brown continued, leading Potter to adjourn the meeting in frustration.

Why it matters

The incident highlights ongoing tensions within the Whitehall City Council over Dixon's past charges and the council's attempts to remove him, despite the charges being dropped. It raises questions about free speech rights during council meetings and the ability of local government to address allegations of misconduct by its own members.

The details

During the Feb. 3 council meeting, as members were giving their final comments, Brown launched into a speech attacking Dixon, who had been accused in December of having sexual contact with several minors dating back to the 1990s. Those charges were later withdrawn by prosecutors. Council President Potter repeatedly tried to stop Brown's speech and threatened to adjourn the meeting early if he didn't, but Brown refused to stop. Eventually, a frustrated Potter adjourned the meeting.

  • The council meeting took place on February 3, 2026.
  • Dixon was arrested on December 8 after police executed a search warrant at his home.
  • The criminal charges against Dixon were dismissed on December 23 in Franklin County Municipal Court.

The players

Devin Brown

Whitehall City Council member who oversees Ward 4 and spoke out against fellow council member Gerald Dixon during the meeting.

Thomas Potter

Whitehall City Council President who repeatedly tried to stop Brown's speech and eventually adjourned the meeting.

Gerald Dixon

Whitehall City Council member who was accused of sex crimes involving minors in the 1990s, though the charges were later dropped.

Michael Bivens

Whitehall Mayor who called for Dixon to resign following his arrest.

Michael Crispen

Whitehall Police Chief who penned a letter to Mayor Bivens outlining Dixon's journals and writings about his attraction to pubescent boys.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“We cannot let this be the Wild West.”

— Thomas Potter, Whitehall City Council President (dispatch.com)

“It's disappointing to be shut down in that way, but I have to live with myself every day, and I feel good about what I did.”

— Devin Brown, Whitehall City Council member (dispatch.com)

“The writings are his personal journals. As far as I know, he hasn't acted on them.”

— Brian McCann, Whitehall City Council member (dispatch.com)

What’s next

The Whitehall City Council is expected to continue discussing Dixon's status and the possibility of removing him from his seat, despite the dropped charges.

The takeaway

This incident highlights the ongoing challenges local governments face in addressing allegations of misconduct by their own elected officials, even when criminal charges are dropped. It raises questions about balancing free speech rights and the ability of councils to maintain order during meetings.