Quarterback Ty Simpson's Draft Fate Remains Uncertain

Alabama prospect's polarizing profile leaves NFL teams divided on his potential

Apr. 13, 2026 at 2:56am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A cubist-style painting depicting a quarterback's throwing motion broken down into sharp, overlapping geometric shapes and planes, representing the multifaceted evaluation of Ty Simpson's draft prospects.The complex geometry of a quarterback's draft prospects, as teams must navigate the uncertainties surrounding Ty Simpson's potential.Cleveland Today

The 2027 NFL Draft is approaching, and all eyes are on quarterback Ty Simpson from the University of Alabama. Despite his college success, Simpson's draft stock remains uncertain as teams debate his readiness for the pro level. With a limited sample size of only 15 starts, Simpson's abilities have been evaluated differently by various scouts, leading to a wide range of projections from potential first-round pick to a slide into the second or third round.

Why it matters

Simpson's draft position will have a significant impact on the quarterback landscape in the NFL. Teams in need of a long-term solution at the position, such as the Cleveland Browns, must weigh the risks and rewards of selecting Simpson early versus waiting for a potentially stronger QB class in 2027.

The details

Some scouts praise Simpson's potential, while others question his readiness for the NFL due to his limited college experience. His 6-foot-1 stature may also be a factor, as the league has trended towards taller, more mobile quarterbacks in recent years. The Browns, holding two first-round picks, have hosted Simpson for a visit but don't seem convinced he's a first-round talent, potentially opting to target a passer in the middle rounds instead.

  • The 2027 NFL Draft is scheduled for April 2027.

The players

Ty Simpson

A quarterback prospect from the University of Alabama who has generated polarizing opinions among NFL scouts due to his limited college experience and physical attributes.

Fernando Mendoza

A quarterback prospect in the 2027 NFL Draft class who is considered one of the top passers, providing a contrast to the uncertainty surrounding Ty Simpson.

Shedeur Sanders

A quarterback prospect who was projected as a first-round pick in the 2026 NFL Draft but ended up being selected in the fifth round, a lesson the Cleveland Browns may apply to their evaluation of Ty Simpson.

Dillon Gabriel

A quarterback prospect who could be an option for the Cleveland Browns if they decide to target a passer in the middle rounds of the 2027 NFL Draft instead of selecting Ty Simpson early.

Cleveland Browns

An NFL team that holds two first-round picks in the 2027 NFL Draft and has been linked to Ty Simpson, but their actions suggest they may not be fully convinced he is a first-round talent.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Some see him as a potential first-round pick, while others predict a slide into the second or even third round.”

— The Author

“This is a crucial decision for the Browns, who are in dire need of a long-term solution at the quarterback position.”

— The Author

What’s next

The Cleveland Browns will continue to evaluate Ty Simpson and other quarterback prospects leading up to the 2027 NFL Draft, as they look to secure a long-term solution at the position.

The takeaway

The uncertainty surrounding Ty Simpson's draft stock highlights the subjective nature of talent evaluation in the NFL. Teams must weigh the potential risks and rewards of selecting a quarterback with limited college experience, especially with a potentially stronger QB class on the horizon in 2027.