Browns Debate Myles Garrett Trade Amid Rebuild

Analysts weigh pros and cons of trading star pass rusher to accelerate team's overhaul.

Apr. 10, 2026 at 11:08am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A cubist, geometric painting depicting a fragmented Cleveland Browns football game, with sharp planes of orange, brown, and white representing the team's strategic dilemma.The Browns' difficult decision on star pass rusher Myles Garrett exposes the complex tradeoffs of rebuilding an NFL roster.Cleveland Today

In the wake of another disappointing Browns season, analysts are debating whether the team should consider trading star defensive end Myles Garrett to jumpstart a full-scale rebuild. While Garrett is one of the NFL's elite pass rushers, some argue his value could be maximized in a trade to acquire multiple high draft picks and accelerate the team's overhaul.

Why it matters

The Browns have struggled to build a consistent winner around Garrett, and some believe a Garrett trade could provide the draft capital needed to fully restock the roster with young talent. However, others argue Garrett is too valuable to trade away, as he is a game-changing defensive player who could be the centerpiece of the team's next contending window.

The details

Analysts Ken Carman and Anthony Lima discussed the Browns' outlook for the upcoming season, including potential offensive improvements. They also reacted to comments from NFL insider Mike Florio suggesting the Browns should consider trading Garrett to acquire multiple high draft picks and accelerate the team's rebuild.

  • The Browns are coming off another disappointing season in 2025.
  • Analysts are debating a potential Myles Garrett trade in the 2026 offseason.

The players

Myles Garrett

A star defensive end for the Cleveland Browns who is considered one of the NFL's elite pass rushers.

Ken Carman

A sports analyst who discussed the Browns' outlook and a potential Garrett trade on the 92.3 The Fan radio program.

Anthony Lima

A sports analyst who discussed the Browns' outlook and a potential Garrett trade on the 92.3 The Fan radio program.

Mike Florio

An NFL insider who suggested the Browns should consider trading Myles Garrett to jumpstart a full-scale rebuild.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Constant speculation about Myles Garrett being traded is frustrating. He's one of the best players in the league and the heart of this team.”

— Ken Carman, Sports Analyst

The takeaway

The debate over Myles Garrett's future in Cleveland highlights the difficult decisions facing the Browns as they try to build a consistent winner. While trading Garrett could provide valuable draft capital, the team must weigh the long-term impact of losing an elite defensive talent against the potential benefits of a full-scale rebuild.