Browns Analysts Debate Trading Myles Garrett for Eagles QB Jalen Hurts

Local radio hosts discuss whether Cleveland should swap their star pass rusher for Philadelphia's young quarterback.

Apr. 1, 2026 at 7:35pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Local Cleveland radio analysts are debating whether the Browns should trade their star edge rusher Myles Garrett to the Philadelphia Eagles in exchange for quarterback Jalen Hurts. The hosts are divided on the potential deal, with one saying he would make the trade without hesitation while the others express concerns about Hurts' reported reluctance to follow coaches' instructions.

Why it matters

The Browns have built a dominant defense in recent years, with Garrett as the centerpiece. However, the team has struggled on offense and at the quarterback position. Acquiring Hurts could potentially solve their QB issues, but there are questions about his coachability and fit in Cleveland.

The details

Myles Garrett, a 7-time Pro Bowler and 2-time Defensive Player of the Year, has been the backbone of the Browns' defense over the past decade. After requesting a trade in 2024, the Browns re-signed him to a lucrative extension. Meanwhile, Jalen Hurts has led the Eagles to two Super Bowl appearances, winning one, since being drafted in 2020. However, there are reports that Hurts has been reluctant to follow his coaches' instructions, leading to speculation about his future in Philadelphia.

  • Garrett signed a contract extension with the Browns in 2025 after requesting a trade.
  • Hurts has been the Eagles' starting quarterback since 2020, leading the team to two Super Bowl appearances.

The players

Myles Garrett

A 7-time Pro Bowler and 2-time Defensive Player of the Year, Garrett has been the star of the Browns' defense for the past decade.

Jalen Hurts

The Eagles' starting quarterback since 2020, Hurts has led the team to two Super Bowl appearances, winning one.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“I like me some Jalen Hurts a lot, but if he's not doing what the coaches are telling him to do, do you want him coming here?”

— Tony Rizzo, ESPN Cleveland Host

“If the Eagles called and offered a one-to-one swap of Hurts and Garrett, I would make the trade without hesitation.”

— Aaron Goldhammer, ESPN Cleveland Host

What’s next

The Browns and Eagles would need to decide whether to pursue a trade involving Garrett and Hurts, and the Browns would need to evaluate Hurts' fit and coachability in their system.

The takeaway

This debate highlights the difficult tradeoffs teams face when trying to balance their roster strengths and weaknesses. The Browns have built a dominant defense, but their offense has struggled, leading them to consider trading their star pass rusher for a potential franchise quarterback in Hurts. However, Hurts' reported issues with following coaches' instructions raise concerns about his fit in Cleveland.