Cincinnati Moeller QB Matt Ponatoski Commits to Kentucky, Citing Baseball Coach Nick Mingione

Ponatoski, a four-star QB, plans to play both football and baseball at UK.

Published on Mar. 8, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Matt Ponatoski, a standout quarterback from Cincinnati Moeller High School, has committed to play for the University of Kentucky, citing his strong relationship with Wildcats baseball coach Nick Mingione as a key factor in his decision. Ponatoski, who threw for over 10,000 yards and 118 touchdowns in high school, made it clear to recruiters that he wanted to play both football and baseball in college.

Why it matters

Ponatoski's commitment is a major coup for Kentucky, as he is considered one of the top dual-sport athletes in the 2026 recruiting class. His ability to excel at both football and baseball makes him a rare and valuable prospect, and Kentucky's willingness to accommodate his desire to play both sports gives them a significant advantage in landing him.

The details

Ponatoski's mother, Becky, said the relationship with Coach Mingione and the Kentucky baseball program was a crucial factor in her son's decision. She noted that Mingione's positive, upbeat personality and the program's focus on faith and family resonated with Ponatoski. The entire Kentucky coaching staff's energy and enthusiasm also appealed to the young athlete, who is known for his competitive drive and work ethic.

  • Ponatoski threw for 10,145 yards and 118 touchdowns with only 14 interceptions during his high school career at Cincinnati Moeller.

The players

Matt Ponatoski

A four-star quarterback from Cincinnati Moeller High School who has also been ranked as a top 20 high school baseball prospect in the 2026 class by Baseball America.

Nick Mingione

The head baseball coach at the University of Kentucky, known for his positive, upbeat personality and the program's focus on faith and family.

Becky Ponatoski

The mother of Matt Ponatoski, who discussed her son's decision to commit to Kentucky and his desire to play both football and baseball in college.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“The relationship with coach Mingione was important. Coach Mingione was great. We had such a wonderful visit with him.”

— Becky Ponatoski, Mother of Matt Ponatoski

“Matt also really liked his faith and how God is in the center of his program and his life. Matt wants to be part of that. Then the whole baseball staff was so energetic, and Matt really thrives in that type of environment.”

— Becky Ponatoski, Mother of Matt Ponatoski

The takeaway

Ponatoski's commitment to Kentucky showcases the school's ability to attract top-tier dual-sport athletes, who are increasingly rare in today's highly specialized sports landscape. Kentucky's willingness to accommodate Ponatoski's desire to play both football and baseball, combined with the strong relationships he and his family developed with the coaching staff, make this a significant recruiting win for the Wildcats.