Geauga County Republican Seeks to Censure Commissioners

Controversy over NOACA bylaw changes leads to calls for disciplinary action

Published on Feb. 12, 2026

A member of the Geauga County Republican Central Committee is seeking to censure Geauga County commissioners Jim Dvorak and Carolyn Brakey following a vote to approve changes to the bylaws of the Northeast Ohio Areawide Coordinating Agency (NOACA). The new regulations require NOACA board members and alternates to be elected officials or county employees with expertise in transportation, planning or other specialized fields.

Why it matters

The proposed censure highlights ongoing political tensions in Geauga County over regional planning and transportation issues. The NOACA bylaw changes were controversial, with one commissioner voting against them, and now there are calls from within the local Republican party to discipline the two commissioners who supported the changes.

The details

The effort to censure Dvorak and Brakey stems from a Jan. 22 vote in which commissioners approved, 2-1, the ratification of changes to NOACA's bylaws. Commissioner Ralph Spidalieri voted against the changes, while Brakey and Dvorak voted in favor. The new NOACA regulations require board members and alternates to be elected officials or county employees with expertise in transportation, planning or other specialized fields.

  • The Geauga County Republican Central Committee member is seeking to censure Dvorak and Brakey following the Jan. 22 NOACA bylaw vote.
  • The commissioners voted 2-1 to approve the NOACA bylaw changes on Jan. 22, 2026.

The players

Jim Dvorak

Geauga County commissioner who voted in favor of the NOACA bylaw changes.

Carolyn Brakey

Geauga County commissioner who voted in favor of the NOACA bylaw changes.

Ralph Spidalieri

Geauga County commissioner who voted against the NOACA bylaw changes.

Geauga County Republican Central Committee

The local Republican party organization seeking to censure Dvorak and Brakey.

Northeast Ohio Areawide Coordinating Agency (NOACA)

The regional planning agency whose bylaw changes sparked the controversy.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

The Geauga County Republican Central Committee will likely vote on whether to censure Dvorak and Brakey in the coming weeks.

The takeaway

This dispute highlights the ongoing political tensions in Geauga County over regional planning issues and the willingness of local Republican officials to discipline their own party members over policy disagreements.