Allegany County's Top Softball Stars Return for 2026 Season

After heavy graduation losses, a new crop of standout players emerge in the region.

Apr. 10, 2026 at 9:43am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A cubist, geometric painting depicting a high school softball game, with the players and field broken down into overlapping planes of deep blue, forest green, and ochre, conveying the dynamic energy and competitive spirit of the sport.A new wave of softball talent from Allegany County emerges to continue the region's proud athletic tradition.Rochester Today

The 2026 All-Greater Rochester softball team will see a significant roster turnover, with 12 of the 17 first-team selections from the previous year having graduated. However, a new generation of talented players from Allegany County is poised to make their mark on the regional softball scene.

Why it matters

The All-Greater Rochester softball team is a prestigious honor that recognizes the top high school players in the Rochester metropolitan area. With many star players from last year's squad moving on, this season represents an opportunity for a new wave of talent to establish themselves and continue the region's softball tradition.

The details

Among the notable departures is Haverling's Kaili Witherell, who was named the Player of the Year in 2025. With the top players from last season gone, the 2026 All-Greater Rochester team will feature a fresh crop of standout athletes, many hailing from Allegany County schools.

  • The 2026 All-Greater Rochester softball team will be announced in April 2026.
  • The 2025 All-Greater Rochester softball team was announced in April 2025.

The players

Kaili Witherell

A standout player from Haverling High School who was named the 2025 Player of the Year on the All-Greater Rochester softball team.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

The takeaway

The 2026 All-Greater Rochester softball team will feature a new generation of talented players, many hailing from Allegany County schools, as the region looks to continue its strong softball tradition after the departure of several star players from the previous year.