The Legendary Rock Critic Who Graded the Counterculture

A captivating documentary explores the life and work of Robert Christgau, the pioneering music writer who invented his own singular style of criticism.

Mar. 29, 2026 at 5:49pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

An abstract close-up image of a shattered disco ball, its glittering shards reflecting dramatic studio lighting to create a high-contrast, high-fashion aesthetic that conceptually represents the influential and pioneering voice of music critic Robert Christgau.The documentary 'The Last Critic' offers a captivating portrait of the legendary music writer Robert Christgau, whose singular critical voice and approach helped define the art of rock criticism.Queens Today

A new documentary, 'The Last Critic,' offers a captivating portrait of Robert Christgau, the legendary music writer who was one of the founding fathers of rock criticism. The film explores how Christgau, through his influential 'Christgau's Consumer Guide' column in the Village Voice, invented his own distinctive style of criticism - blending acerbic wit, deep insight, and a compulsive need to grade and categorize every album he reviewed.

Why it matters

Christgau was a pivotal figure who helped establish rock criticism as a vital and respected art form, influencing generations of music writers. The documentary sheds light on his unique approach, which often challenged the counterculture ethos of the era, and his enduring impact on the way we think about and consume music.

The details

Born in 1942, Christgau started out as a gifted writer and reporter before being recruited by Esquire magazine in the 1960s to cover youth culture. It was there that he launched his influential 'Christgau's Consumer Guide' column, which evaluated and graded the latest rock albums in a distinctive, poetic style. Christgau's reviews, which ran in the Village Voice for decades, were known for their acerbic wit, deep musical knowledge, and willingness to buck critical consensus. The documentary explores Christgau's singular approach, from his compulsive need to maintain an encyclopedic collection of 36,000 vinyl albums and CDs, to his reputation as a 'literary dictator' who would sometimes bike over to writers' apartments to ensure they met their deadlines. It also delves into his friendships and rivalries with other pioneering rock critics like Greil Marcus and Lester Bangs, and his role in shaping the diverse, progressive voice of the Village Voice's music coverage.

  • Christgau started his 'Christgau's Consumer Guide' column at Esquire in the late 1960s.
  • The column ran in the Village Voice for decades, from the 1970s through the 1990s.
  • Christgau, now 83 years old, continues to write the Consumer Guide, which is now published on Substack.

The players

Robert Christgau

A pioneering music critic who invented his own distinctive style of rock criticism, known for his acerbic wit, deep musical knowledge, and willingness to challenge critical consensus. He launched the influential 'Christgau's Consumer Guide' column in the 1960s.

Greil Marcus

A legendary rock critic based on the West Coast, who had a close friendship and intellectual rivalry with Christgau.

Lester Bangs

A brilliant but troubled rock critic who was part of the founding generation of rock criticism, alongside Christgau and others.

Ellen Willis

Another pioneering rock critic who was part of the same circle as Christgau and Marcus.

Caroline Dibbell

Christgau's wife, with whom he has lived in the same New York apartment for 50 years.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“To the eternal 'Opinions are like assholes — everyone's got one,' I just say, but not everybody's got ten thousand of them.”

— Robert Christgau, Music Critic

“I don't think he feels hip-hop. And I think that's a function of whether you feel James Brown. And that's a real gap.”

— Greil Marcus, Music Critic

“I love African music, I really love some country music, I like the best of what's called world music, I love rap, I've got nothing against pop, I like funk and dance music quite a lot...”

— Robert Christgau

The takeaway

The documentary 'The Last Critic' is a testament to the power and artistry of great music criticism, embodied by the singular figure of Robert Christgau. It shows how Christgau's distinctive voice and approach - blending acerbic wit, deep musical knowledge, and a compulsive need to categorize and grade - helped establish rock criticism as a vital and respected art form, influencing generations of writers.