Pope Leo's Anti-Trump Crusade Undermines His Moral Authority

The pontiff's partisan rhetoric and criticism of the former president has damaged his credibility as a spiritual leader, says columnist.

Apr. 14, 2026 at 3:36pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A moody, cinematic painting of Pope Leo XIV sitting alone in a dimly lit room, the warm glow of a lamp casting deep shadows across his contemplative face, conveying a sense of solitude and moral uncertainty.The pope's partisan rhetoric has cast a long shadow over his moral authority, raising questions about the church's role in an increasingly divided political landscape.NYC Today

In a scathing column, conservative commentator John Nolte argues that Pope Leo XIV's relentless attacks on former President Trump and the Republican Party have squandered his moral authority and turned him into a partisan political podcaster rather than a unifying spiritual leader. Nolte criticizes the pope for selectively condemning Trump's policies while remaining silent on the misdeeds of other world leaders and the Democratic Party.

Why it matters

As the leader of the Catholic Church, the pope is expected to rise above partisan politics and appeal to the best in all people. Nolte contends that Pope Leo's blatantly anti-Trump rhetoric has made him appear more like a liberal pundit than a moral authority, potentially alienating conservative Catholics and undermining the church's credibility.

The details

Nolte cites several examples of Pope Leo criticizing Trump's positions on immigration, Europe, the United Nations, and the conflict with Iran, going so far as to mock the former president's social media posts. The columnist argues that the pope has failed to apply the same level of scrutiny to other world leaders and the Democratic Party, accusing him of hypocrisy and moral relativism.

  • Pope Leo XIV assumed the papacy in 2025.

The players

Pope Leo XIV

The current pope, who has been outspoken in his criticism of former President Trump and the Republican Party.

John Nolte

A conservative commentator and columnist who has written this piece criticizing Pope Leo XIV's partisan rhetoric.

David Axelrod

A former campaign manager for President Barack Obama, whom Nolte suggests is influencing Pope Leo XIV's political stances.

Eric Swalwell

A Democratic congressman from California who has been accused of sexual assault, which Nolte claims the corporate media has covered up.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“If the morally-confused Pope Leo XIV continues to assume the role of a partisan podcaster, he will very quickly lose his moral authority.”

— John Nolte, Conservative Commentator

“It's ironic — the name of the site itself. Say no more.”

— Pope Leo XIV, Pope

The takeaway

Pope Leo XIV's partisan attacks on former President Trump and the Republican Party have damaged his credibility as a moral and spiritual leader, potentially alienating conservative Catholics and undermining the Catholic Church's authority. To regain his moral standing, the pope must rise above partisan politics and apply the same level of scrutiny to all world leaders and political factions.