Yankees Fans Demand Star Player's Trade After Costly Mistake

Jazz Chisholm Jr. admits to not understanding game rules after blunder in extra-innings loss.

Apr. 13, 2026 at 2:08am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A fragmented, geometric painting depicting a baseball player's throwing motion, with sharp planes of muted earth tones representing the Yankees' tumultuous start to the season.A cubist interpretation of a Yankees player's critical throwing error, reflecting the team's struggles and fractured season.NYC Today

New York Yankees fans are calling for the team to trade star player Jazz Chisholm Jr. after a costly mistake in an extra-innings loss to the Tampa Bay Rays. Chisholm Jr. revealed in a postgame interview that he didn't understand the rules that led to his throwing error, further angering fans who see him as a problem with the struggling 8-7 Yankees.

Why it matters

The Yankees had high expectations coming into the 2026 season, but have stumbled to an 8-7 start, including a sweep at the hands of the Rays. Chisholm Jr., who had hoped to emulate Shohei Ohtani's 50-50 season, has yet to hit a home run and made a critical mistake that cost the team a game, leading to calls from fans to trade the struggling star.

The details

In Saturday's extra-innings loss to the Rays, Chisholm Jr. made a throwing error that allowed the winning run to score. In a postgame interview, he admitted he didn't understand the rules that led to the mistake. Yankees fans are now clamoring for the team to trade Chisholm Jr., who has yet to hit a home run this season despite his preseason goal of 50 homers and 50 stolen bases.

  • The Yankees started the 2026 season 7-1 before being swept by the Rays.
  • On Saturday, Chisholm Jr. made the costly throwing error in extra innings against the Rays.

The players

Jazz Chisholm Jr.

A star player for the New York Yankees who had hoped to emulate Shohei Ohtani's 50-50 season but has struggled mightily to start the 2026 campaign.

Gerrit Cole

The Yankees' ace pitcher who is expected to return from injury and help bolster the team's pitching staff.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“I didn't understand the rules that led to that mistake. It's on me.”

— Jazz Chisholm Jr., Yankees Player

What’s next

The Yankees will have to decide whether to keep Chisholm Jr. on the roster or explore trading options for the struggling star player.

The takeaway

This incident highlights the high expectations and intense scrutiny the Yankees face, as well as the challenges of integrating new star players into the lineup. Chisholm Jr.'s admission of not understanding the rules has further angered the fanbase and put his future with the team in doubt.