Staten Island's Egger's Ice Cream Wins Brooklyn SeltzerFest 2026

Beloved parlor takes home top prize for its signature egg cream creation.

Apr. 12, 2026 at 7:35pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A vibrant, high-contrast silkscreen print featuring a repeated image of a classic egg cream glass in a grid pattern, using a bold, neon color palette to capture the energy and creativity of the Brooklyn SeltzerFest.Egger's Ice Cream's award-winning egg cream recipe takes center stage at the Brooklyn SeltzerFest, a celebration of New York's carbonated beverage culture.NYC Today

Egger's Ice Cream, a Staten Island institution dating back to 1932, has emerged victorious at the Brooklyn SeltzerFest 2026, a celebration of New York's carbonated beverage culture. Competing for the third time, Egger's beat out contestants from across the region, impressing the judges with its perfected egg cream recipe and mixing techniques.

Why it matters

The Brooklyn SeltzerFest is a unique event that showcases the rich history and enduring appeal of seltzer and egg creams in New York City. Egger's triumph is a testament to the power of tradition and innovation, as the beloved ice cream parlor has maintained its old-fashioned charm while evolving to cater to modern tastes.

The details

The festival, which drew over a thousand enthusiasts, featured comedy, music, and of course, egg cream showdowns. Egger's owner Danielle Raleigh Carr shared her practice regimen and the secret to her success - perfecting the art of the egg cream. The judges, including an Emmy-nominated actress and soda fountain experts, evaluated mixing techniques and foam heights before crowning Egger's the champion.

  • The Brooklyn SeltzerFest 2026 took place on April 12, 2026.
  • Egger's Ice Cream has been a Staten Island institution since 1932.

The players

Egger's Ice Cream

A beloved ice cream parlor in Staten Island, New York, with a rich history dating back to 1932. The parlor has maintained its old-fashioned charm while evolving to cater to modern tastes.

Danielle Raleigh Carr

The owner of Egger's Ice Cream, who shared her practice regimen and the secret to her success in perfecting the art of the egg cream.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

Egger's Ice Cream plans to celebrate its victory at the Brooklyn SeltzerFest 2026 with a special event at its Staten Island location, featuring live music, festive decorations, and of course, plenty of egg creams.

The takeaway

Egger's triumph at the Brooklyn SeltzerFest 2026 is a heartwarming story of a small, family-owned business that has managed to preserve its rich history and traditions while adapting to changing times. It's a reminder that with dedication, innovation, and a commitment to quality, even the most beloved local institutions can continue to thrive and delight their communities.