Bronx Judge Draws Outrage for Sentencing Cop Who Killed Fleeing Suspect

Readers condemn decision to imprison Sgt. Erik Duran for 2023 shooting death during drug bust

Apr. 10, 2026 at 8:41pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

An extreme close-up of a police badge or handcuffs, the harsh lighting creating dramatic shadows and textures that convey a sense of the gritty realities of law enforcement.The harsh, unforgiving light of a police investigation exposes the tensions between law enforcement and the criminal justice system.NYC Today

Readers of the New York Post are expressing outrage over a Bronx judge's decision to sentence Sgt. Erik Duran to prison for killing a man who was fleeing from a 2023 drug bust. The judge, Guy Mitchell, has been accused of treating the suspect, Eric Duprey, as equal to the police officer, despite Duprey being a criminal with no regard for public safety. Readers argue that Duran was simply doing his job to protect the public, and that the judge's decision sends a dangerous message that will discourage police from enforcing the law.

Why it matters

This case highlights the ongoing tensions between law enforcement and the criminal justice system, as well as the challenges police officers face in balancing public safety with the use of force. The judge's decision has been widely criticized as being overly lenient towards the suspect and unfairly punishing the officer who was trying to apprehend a dangerous criminal.

The details

According to the letters, Sgt. Erik Duran was involved in a 2023 drug bust in the Bronx where the suspect, Eric Duprey, attempted to flee the scene. Duran shot and killed Duprey, who the readers describe as a "criminal with no regard for innocent people." However, Judge Guy Mitchell sentenced Duran to prison, drawing outrage from readers who argue that the judge was treating the officer and the suspect as equals despite their vastly different roles and actions.

  • In 2023, Sgt. Erik Duran was involved in a drug bust where he shot and killed a fleeing suspect, Eric Duprey.
  • On April 10, 2026, a Bronx judge named Guy Mitchell sentenced Sgt. Duran to prison for the 2023 shooting.

The players

Sgt. Erik Duran

A police officer who was involved in a 2023 drug bust in the Bronx where he shot and killed a fleeing suspect.

Eric Duprey

The suspect who was fleeing from the 2023 drug bust in the Bronx and was shot and killed by Sgt. Duran.

Judge Guy Mitchell

The Bronx judge who sentenced Sgt. Duran to prison for the 2023 shooting death of Eric Duprey.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Thanks to Judge Guy Mitchell, hard-working, crime-fighting cops like ex-Sgt. Erik Duran are going to prison, while gang members and murderers are set free to prey upon law-abiding citizens.”

— Greg Cantiello, Resident

“The criminal here is the judge who imposed this sentence on Duran. It's clear Duran did not want to kill Eric Duprey, but stop him from killing innocent pedestrians while escaping.”

— Miriam Fiber, Resident

“Duran showed remorse and needs retraining, not jail time. How can these judges expect our streets to remain safe if there is the fear of going to prison for arresting criminals?”

— Greg Raleigh, Resident

What’s next

Sgt. Duran's legal team is expected to appeal the judge's decision, though the outcome remains uncertain given the political climate in New York.

The takeaway

This case highlights the growing divide between law enforcement and the criminal justice system, as well as the challenges police officers face in balancing public safety with the use of force. The judge's decision to imprison Sgt. Duran has been widely criticized as being overly lenient towards the suspect and unfairly punishing the officer who was trying to apprehend a dangerous criminal.