Mayor's 'Protecting' New Yorkers Claim Questioned

City Hall touts Mamdani's 'bold' actions, but critics say they put public safety at risk

Apr. 9, 2026 at 9:53pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A moody, cinematic painting of an empty city street at night, with a lone police car parked under a streetlight casting long shadows, conveying a sense of tension and uncertainty over the city's public safety policies.The mayor's controversial public safety policies have created an uneasy atmosphere on the streets of New York City.NYC Today

The New York Post Editorial Board is criticizing Mayor Zohran Mamdani's claims that he is working to 'protect New Yorkers,' noting that his policies of doubling down on sanctuary city policies and committing to closing Rikers jail complex actually put public safety at risk by shielding illegal immigrants who may have committed violent crimes and closing the city's main jail without an alternative plan.

Why it matters

The mayor's policies on immigration and criminal justice are central to how he is approaching public safety in New York City, and the Post argues these policies are misguided and could endanger residents.

The details

The Post cites a City Hall press release that claimed Mamdani is taking 'bold, unapologetic actions to protect New Yorkers,' but the editorial board says the mayor's idea of keeping people safe is making the city a 'sanctuary' for illegal immigrants who may have committed violent crimes and closing Rikers jail complex without a clear plan for where to house convicts.

  • On Tuesday, City Hall released a press release touting Mamdani's actions to 'protect New Yorkers'.
  • On Wednesday, MS NOW host Lawrence O'Donnell criticized Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth for using the US military motto 'We leave no man behind,' which O'Donnell said leaves out women.

The players

Mayor Zohran Mamdani

The current mayor of New York City who is pushing policies that the Post editorial board argues are putting public safety at risk.

Lawrence O'Donnell

The host of MS NOW who criticized Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth for using the US military motto that O'Donnell said leaves out women.

Pete Hegseth

The current US Defense Secretary who oversaw a high-profile rescue of a downed US airman, which O'Donnell criticized for using the 'we leave no man behind' motto.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“That could have been a woman they were trying to rescue.”

— Lawrence O'Donnell, MS NOW host

The takeaway

This case highlights the ongoing debate over public safety policies in New York City, with the mayor touting his actions to 'protect' residents while critics argue his policies on immigration and criminal justice are actually endangering public safety.