Yankees Reportedly Considering Trading Top Prospect Volpe to Brewers

A recent mock trade proposal suggests the Yankees could move on from their highly touted shortstop prospect.

Apr. 8, 2026 at 11:20pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A fragmented, geometric painting depicting a baseball player's motion, with sharp, overlapping planes of color and form representing the complex factors the Yankees must consider in Volpe's trade potential.A cubist interpretation of a baseball player's motion captures the dynamic energy and uncertainty surrounding the Yankees' decision on Anthony Volpe's future.NYC Today

The New York Yankees are reportedly considering trading away top prospect Anthony Volpe to the Milwaukee Brewers, according to a recent mock trade proposal. Volpe, a 24-year-old shortstop, has struggled to find consistent success at the major league level so far in his young career, leading the Yankees to potentially explore moving him in a deal that would net them pitching prospect Robert Gasser and infielder Andrew Fischer from the Brewers.

Why it matters

The potential Volpe trade would be a surprising move by the Yankees, who have long touted the young shortstop as a key part of their future plans. However, with the team's current roster depth and Volpe's underwhelming MLB performance to date, the Yankees may feel it's the right time to cash in on his prospect value before it declines further.

The details

In the proposed trade, the Yankees would send Volpe to the Brewers in exchange for pitching prospect Robert Gasser and infielder Andrew Fischer. Gasser is currently recovering from an arm injury and has yet to make his Triple-A debut, while the young Fischer recently impressed during the World Baseball Classic playing for Italy. The Yankees' rationale for the deal is that they have other internal options at shortstop, including José Caballero, Amed Rosario, and Ryan McMahon, allowing them to potentially move on from Volpe.

  • Volpe could rejoin the Yankees soon and may go on a rehab assignment soon, according to manager Aaron Boone.

The players

Anthony Volpe

A 24-year-old shortstop prospect in the Yankees' farm system who has struggled to find consistent success at the major league level so far in his young career.

Robert Gasser

A pitching prospect in the Brewers' farm system who is currently recovering from an arm injury and has yet to make his Triple-A debut.

Andrew Fischer

A young infielder in the Brewers' farm system who recently impressed during the World Baseball Classic playing for Italy.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“The Yankees could realistically move Anthony Volpe to the Brewers because of roster depth and positional flexibility. In 2026, the Yankees will already have José Caballero, Amed Rosario, and Ryan McMahon capable of playing shortstop or third base, giving the team multiple internal options to cover Volpe's position.”

— Ryan Shea, Writer

What’s next

The Yankees will have to decide whether to give Volpe another extended opportunity to prove himself at the major league level or if they will pull the trigger on a trade that could net them pitching and infield depth.

The takeaway

This potential trade highlights the difficult decisions the Yankees face with their top prospects, as they must balance long-term potential with short-term roster needs and production. Volpe's struggles have led the team to explore moving on from him, but the return package may not be enough to convince them to part ways with the highly touted shortstop just yet.