Yankees Bench Ryan McMahon, Start Amed Rosario Against Athletics

Unexpected lineup change as Yankees face right-handed pitcher Aaron Civale

Apr. 8, 2026 at 9:54pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A cubist, geometric painting depicting a baseball game in progress, with the players and field broken down into overlapping planes of navy, white, gray, green, and gold.The Yankees' lineup decision to sit their regular third baseman against a right-handed pitcher reflects an unconventional strategic approach to gain an edge over their opponent.NYC Today

The New York Yankees made a surprising decision to start Amed Rosario at third base instead of Ryan McMahon in their game against the Oakland Athletics, even though they were facing a right-handed pitcher in Aaron Civale. Yankees manager Aaron Boone explained that Civale has reverse splits, making the matchup favorable for Rosario.

Why it matters

This move by the Yankees' coaching staff is noteworthy as it goes against the typical platoon strategy of starting right-handed hitters against right-handed pitchers. It suggests the team sees a specific advantage in having Rosario face Civale, despite the pitcher's standard profile.

The details

Amed Rosario, who is normally a shortstop, started at third base for the Yankees in place of Ryan McMahon. This was an unexpected lineup decision, as McMahon is the team's regular third baseman. Yankees manager Aaron Boone explained that the move was due to Athletics pitcher Aaron Civale having reverse splits, meaning he is more effective against right-handed hitters than left-handed ones.

  • The Yankees faced the Athletics on April 7, 2026.

The players

Amed Rosario

A utility infielder for the New York Yankees who primarily plays shortstop.

Ryan McMahon

The regular third baseman for the New York Yankees.

Aaron Civale

A right-handed pitcher for the Oakland Athletics.

Aaron Boone

The manager of the New York Yankees.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Not necessarily. There are certain matchups I like him in.”

— Aaron Boone, Yankees Manager

The takeaway

This lineup decision by the Yankees' coaching staff demonstrates their willingness to be flexible and make unconventional choices when they believe it gives their team the best chance to win, even if it means benching a regular starter like Ryan McMahon.